I attended a fundraiser for the Bella Trezza foundation and the atmosphere in the main bar area and the covered veranda was awesomely festive. If you are in Babylon Village and you are looking for a welcoming place to eat some good bar food and watch the game of the day—don’t walk, run to Mary Carroll’s. This establishment will never disappoint its patrons; they treat everyone like family. A great vibe and I was there for a great cause.
Joey
-
January 25, 2026
The cheesecake that they charge 14 dollars for is not worth the price! You can get a better piece of cheesecake at any local diner for half the price! It’s not even a slice. It comes in a small round container. A good NY cheesecake from a diner is 100 times better! Other than that it’s a great atmosphere.
Harry Walsh
-
November 02, 2025
Food was delicious but took no kidding 45 minutes to come out. bartender was more interested in talking with his friends then serving us. We had a bunch of drinks and charged for every one no buybacks I said to him we got no buybacks he said we don’t do that here. Will never be back again and that’s a shame so much potential
Renzo Casco
-
March 03, 2026
Matt and Nick took great care of me. I love a good dive bar and this is the best one you could find in Babylon!!
Darren
-
July 26, 2025
My wings are black. I didn’t even know it was possible to burn wings so bad. Completely inedible. You try and call to complain and then hangup the phone everytime.
Our Address
121 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon, NY 11702, USA
Claim Listing: Mary Caroll’s
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I attended a fundraiser for the Bella Trezza foundation and the atmosphere in the main bar area and the covered veranda was awesomely festive. If you are in Babylon Village and you are looking for a welcoming place to eat some good bar food and watch the game of the day—don’t walk, run to Mary Carroll’s. This establishment will never disappoint its patrons; they treat everyone like family. A great vibe and I was there for a great cause.
The cheesecake that they charge 14 dollars for is not worth the price! You can get a better piece of cheesecake at any local diner for half the price! It’s not even a slice. It comes in a small round container. A good NY cheesecake from a diner is 100 times better! Other than that it’s a great atmosphere.
Food was delicious but took no kidding 45 minutes to come out. bartender was more interested in talking with his friends then serving us. We had a bunch of drinks and charged for every one no buybacks I said to him we got no buybacks he said we don’t do that here. Will never be back again and that’s a shame so much potential
Matt and Nick took great care of me. I love a good dive bar and this is the best one you could find in Babylon!!
My wings are black. I didn’t even know it was possible to burn wings so bad. Completely inedible. You try and call to complain and then hangup the phone everytime.