Pizza, well cooked, slice stands up with one hand hold, crust on the thin side, tasty sauce spiced right, correct amount of cheese and a crunchy crust!
That's as far as I go on this review till we come back, eat in and try an entree!
Atmosphere looks go with a nice dining room.
The pizza takeout was busy with only one employee, taking orders, working the oven, serving, and operating the register.
AND last but not least Cafe Gio charges extra for credit cards... Why?
The pizza was very good, maybe it was all with it? Lmk?
Nicole Croce
-
December 28, 2025
Cafe Gio is truly like a second home to our family. We go every single Christmas Eve, and year after year they make us feel so welcome—even with my three little babies in high chairs. That alone says everything about how accommodating and family-friendly they are.
We’ve celebrated some of our biggest life moments here: communions, christenings, and even my baby shower. Every event has been flawless, and the care they put into making each one special never goes unnoticed.
This past Christmas Eve, I ordered the stuffed Rigatoni Grimaldi and… wow. I’m not exaggerating when I say it was one of the best dishes I’ve ever had. I literally cannot stop thinking about it. Perfection.
The food, the atmosphere, the consistency, the kindness—it’s all there. A huge thank you to Sal and the entire Cafe Gio team for always making us feel like family. We absolutely love it here and wouldn’t celebrate our special moments anywhere else.
— Nikki 💛
Nicholas Egbert
-
September 29, 2025
The absolute best place for pizza on the island. Try their old fashioned slice. They make it just like you get it from Sicily. The breadcrumbs sautéed onions. The sauce and dough is delicious!!!!!
Marvin Fuentes
-
June 09, 2025
Hands down the best pizzeria in the Babylon area. Try the shrimp pesto pizza and their chicken bacon ranch is out of this world. And Leo’s the man; been coming here for years and he’s always helpful
Joe
-
April 27, 2025
It bewilders me how they serve a chicken parm hero with no sauce. I know they didn’t run out of sauce because we also got a shrimp parm hero and it came with some sauce on it. And they have the nerve to charge for extra sauce as in a side order. This order I went and picked up knowing they only use very little sauce and when I get it delivered they never include the extra sauce I ask for in the comments. Makes the hero very dry. So this order I picked up and also ordered the “side” of extra sauce for $1.50. Lucky I did or I would’ve thrown my chicken parm in the trash. Zero sauce on it what a joke. It’s a “side” of sauce not sauce on the side lol. Better place down the road.
Our Address
761 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA
Claim Listing: Cafe Gio
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Pizza, well cooked, slice stands up with one hand hold, crust on the thin side, tasty sauce spiced right, correct amount of cheese and a crunchy crust! That's as far as I go on this review till we come back, eat in and try an entree! Atmosphere looks go with a nice dining room. The pizza takeout was busy with only one employee, taking orders, working the oven, serving, and operating the register. AND last but not least Cafe Gio charges extra for credit cards... Why? The pizza was very good, maybe it was all with it? Lmk?
Cafe Gio is truly like a second home to our family. We go every single Christmas Eve, and year after year they make us feel so welcome—even with my three little babies in high chairs. That alone says everything about how accommodating and family-friendly they are. We’ve celebrated some of our biggest life moments here: communions, christenings, and even my baby shower. Every event has been flawless, and the care they put into making each one special never goes unnoticed. This past Christmas Eve, I ordered the stuffed Rigatoni Grimaldi and… wow. I’m not exaggerating when I say it was one of the best dishes I’ve ever had. I literally cannot stop thinking about it. Perfection. The food, the atmosphere, the consistency, the kindness—it’s all there. A huge thank you to Sal and the entire Cafe Gio team for always making us feel like family. We absolutely love it here and wouldn’t celebrate our special moments anywhere else. — Nikki 💛
The absolute best place for pizza on the island. Try their old fashioned slice. They make it just like you get it from Sicily. The breadcrumbs sautéed onions. The sauce and dough is delicious!!!!!
Hands down the best pizzeria in the Babylon area. Try the shrimp pesto pizza and their chicken bacon ranch is out of this world. And Leo’s the man; been coming here for years and he’s always helpful
It bewilders me how they serve a chicken parm hero with no sauce. I know they didn’t run out of sauce because we also got a shrimp parm hero and it came with some sauce on it. And they have the nerve to charge for extra sauce as in a side order. This order I went and picked up knowing they only use very little sauce and when I get it delivered they never include the extra sauce I ask for in the comments. Makes the hero very dry. So this order I picked up and also ordered the “side” of extra sauce for $1.50. Lucky I did or I would’ve thrown my chicken parm in the trash. Zero sauce on it what a joke. It’s a “side” of sauce not sauce on the side lol. Better place down the road.