I had a surprise party for my parents at Nonna Bella’s and it was a great outcome. The staff is kind, the food was amazing, and the service was great. I was able to decorate the party room hours before the party, and staff was kind enough to offer to help. I highly recommend having a party here!!! The owners of Nonna Bella’s are professional, understanding, and help with anything they can do.
Rand Smythe
-
December 14, 2025
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Nonna Bella’s is truly a local gem!
They have one of the best Margherita pizzas around: fresh, flavorful, and perfectly made. The food is consistently amazing, and the service is just as outstanding: friendly, professional, and attentive.
I recently placed my first catering order with Nonna Bella’s, and it was a huge hit, everyone absolutely loved it. The quality, presentation, and overall experience exceeded expectations.
If you’re looking for incredible food and top-notch service, Nonna Bella’s never disappoints. Highly recommend! 🍕✨
Nodir Real estate NY
-
February 08, 2026
This was the worst pizza experience I’ve ever had. The Sicilian pizza we received smelled terrible and tasted awful—it was hard, not fresh, and possibly made with expired ingredients. My son couldn’t eat it either.
I tried to get a regular cheese pizza instead, but the service was extremely frustrating. I spoke to four different employees, each time repeating the order, and they kept saying “okay” but never actually gave us the pizza. We ended up waiting for a very long time.
Additionally, the hygiene was shocking. The staff were touching food with their bare hands and wiping them on their pants, which is completely unacceptable for a food establishment.
In the end, after all the waiting and confusion, the replacement pizza was still terrible. It was just as bad as the first one.
Overall, this was a completely disappointing experience, and I will not be returning.
Margaret Giugliano
-
October 29, 2025
New to the neighborhood and tried Nonna Bella’s on a neighbor recommendation. Was feeding a crowd.— absolutely delicious pizza with the right ratio of sauce to cheese.
Lovely staff. Went back next week for some heros—and again food was great.
Both were to-go orders & food was hot and appealing. As you leave the rear be sure to say hi to the chef stirring the largest pot of sauce you ever saw!!
Maybe not big on atmosphere (although outside tables & umbrellas looked inviting)We found our new go to place.
Frank Serigano
-
December 19, 2025
Food at Nonna Bella is always delicious. We love their sauce. We have never had a bad meal. The staff is always very pleasant and we assume they model themselves after the owner who is a kind and pleasant gentleman. We drive past 4 other Italian places for their excellent customer service and food.
Our Address
765 Deer Pk Ave, North Babylon, NY 11703, USA
Claim Listing: Nonna Bella’s
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I had a surprise party for my parents at Nonna Bella’s and it was a great outcome. The staff is kind, the food was amazing, and the service was great. I was able to decorate the party room hours before the party, and staff was kind enough to offer to help. I highly recommend having a party here!!! The owners of Nonna Bella’s are professional, understanding, and help with anything they can do.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Nonna Bella’s is truly a local gem! They have one of the best Margherita pizzas around: fresh, flavorful, and perfectly made. The food is consistently amazing, and the service is just as outstanding: friendly, professional, and attentive. I recently placed my first catering order with Nonna Bella’s, and it was a huge hit, everyone absolutely loved it. The quality, presentation, and overall experience exceeded expectations. If you’re looking for incredible food and top-notch service, Nonna Bella’s never disappoints. Highly recommend! 🍕✨
This was the worst pizza experience I’ve ever had. The Sicilian pizza we received smelled terrible and tasted awful—it was hard, not fresh, and possibly made with expired ingredients. My son couldn’t eat it either. I tried to get a regular cheese pizza instead, but the service was extremely frustrating. I spoke to four different employees, each time repeating the order, and they kept saying “okay” but never actually gave us the pizza. We ended up waiting for a very long time. Additionally, the hygiene was shocking. The staff were touching food with their bare hands and wiping them on their pants, which is completely unacceptable for a food establishment. In the end, after all the waiting and confusion, the replacement pizza was still terrible. It was just as bad as the first one. Overall, this was a completely disappointing experience, and I will not be returning.
New to the neighborhood and tried Nonna Bella’s on a neighbor recommendation. Was feeding a crowd.— absolutely delicious pizza with the right ratio of sauce to cheese. Lovely staff. Went back next week for some heros—and again food was great. Both were to-go orders & food was hot and appealing. As you leave the rear be sure to say hi to the chef stirring the largest pot of sauce you ever saw!! Maybe not big on atmosphere (although outside tables & umbrellas looked inviting)We found our new go to place.
Food at Nonna Bella is always delicious. We love their sauce. We have never had a bad meal. The staff is always very pleasant and we assume they model themselves after the owner who is a kind and pleasant gentleman. We drive past 4 other Italian places for their excellent customer service and food.