My wife and I enjoyed the service, they were friendly. We went on a Sunday, so we were happy to get parking. Food was a hit and miss. So were the drinks. The margarita was delicious and the short rib wellingtons were amazing. I would recommend giving this restaurant a try.
Joy P
-
August 06, 2025
Delicious food from a generous menu and specials. Nice wine list and cocktail menu! The wait staff members were very friendly, attentive, knowledgable and really nice people!
Michele Kunz
-
September 15, 2025
This place is amazing. Great service, drinks, and the food is awesome. Great weekday price- fixe meals. I had salmon and my husband had filet mignon. Appetizers and sides were the best!! Honestly. Jenn treated us like VIPs. Highly recommended. Can’t wait to go back!
ToniMarie Chiavola
-
June 08, 2025
I had dinner at Argyle Grill & Tavern last night and I can confidently say this place exceeds expectations. From the moment we walked in, the experience was seamless. Although it was busy, we were seated right away, and the staff was incredibly accommodating when we requested a quieter table in the back once one became available.
The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance, lively and social near the bar in the front, with a more intimate dining area in the back for a relaxed meal.
We started with cocktails and they were 10/10 not only delicious but beautifully presented. For appetizers, we went with the tuna rice cakes (highly recommend!), the French onion soup, and were lucky enough to get a taste of the lobster bisque. The owner personally brought it out for us to try, and let me tell you… I’ll be ordering a full bowl next time. It was creamy, buttery, and bursting with flavor, pure comfort in a cup.
We also split a Caesar salad, which came perfectly chopped and lightly dressed, exactly how I like it. For entrees, we had the sea bass, the Gorgonzola strip steak, and the spicy stuffed rigatoni. Every dish was packed with flavor, plated beautifully, and cooked to perfection. We couldn’t help but share bites from each other’s plates because everything was that good.
From service to presentation, everything was top-notch. The menu is so well thought out, it’s honestly hard to choose so I’ll definitely be back to try more! The price reflects the quality, and in my opinion, it’s worth every penny.
Hands down the best dining experience in Babylon Village. You won’t be disappointed. They truly know what they’re doing here.
Lisa Pescetti
-
November 18, 2025
Had a stellar experience last night for dinner. Firstly, our server let us know about the amazing deals they have during the week including complimentary sides with every steak. We ordered two steaks in which both were delicious. What truly stood out was the welcoming environment from the moment we entered. From the hostess to our amazing server Jennifer we felt very special (they even brought us out a free tasting of pasta). Thank you for making our night special for a Monday. We will definitely be returning.
Our Address
90 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon, NY 11702, USA
Claim Listing: Argyle Grill & Tavern
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
My wife and I enjoyed the service, they were friendly. We went on a Sunday, so we were happy to get parking. Food was a hit and miss. So were the drinks. The margarita was delicious and the short rib wellingtons were amazing. I would recommend giving this restaurant a try.
Delicious food from a generous menu and specials. Nice wine list and cocktail menu! The wait staff members were very friendly, attentive, knowledgable and really nice people!
This place is amazing. Great service, drinks, and the food is awesome. Great weekday price- fixe meals. I had salmon and my husband had filet mignon. Appetizers and sides were the best!! Honestly. Jenn treated us like VIPs. Highly recommended. Can’t wait to go back!
I had dinner at Argyle Grill & Tavern last night and I can confidently say this place exceeds expectations. From the moment we walked in, the experience was seamless. Although it was busy, we were seated right away, and the staff was incredibly accommodating when we requested a quieter table in the back once one became available. The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance, lively and social near the bar in the front, with a more intimate dining area in the back for a relaxed meal. We started with cocktails and they were 10/10 not only delicious but beautifully presented. For appetizers, we went with the tuna rice cakes (highly recommend!), the French onion soup, and were lucky enough to get a taste of the lobster bisque. The owner personally brought it out for us to try, and let me tell you… I’ll be ordering a full bowl next time. It was creamy, buttery, and bursting with flavor, pure comfort in a cup. We also split a Caesar salad, which came perfectly chopped and lightly dressed, exactly how I like it. For entrees, we had the sea bass, the Gorgonzola strip steak, and the spicy stuffed rigatoni. Every dish was packed with flavor, plated beautifully, and cooked to perfection. We couldn’t help but share bites from each other’s plates because everything was that good. From service to presentation, everything was top-notch. The menu is so well thought out, it’s honestly hard to choose so I’ll definitely be back to try more! The price reflects the quality, and in my opinion, it’s worth every penny. Hands down the best dining experience in Babylon Village. You won’t be disappointed. They truly know what they’re doing here.
Had a stellar experience last night for dinner. Firstly, our server let us know about the amazing deals they have during the week including complimentary sides with every steak. We ordered two steaks in which both were delicious. What truly stood out was the welcoming environment from the moment we entered. From the hostess to our amazing server Jennifer we felt very special (they even brought us out a free tasting of pasta). Thank you for making our night special for a Monday. We will definitely be returning.