I’ve been dealing with Guy at All Star Comics for the last couple of months, and I have to say that it’s been a pleasure to deal with him. He has helped me find certain silver age comics that I have been looking for to add to my collection. He has never pressured me to buy any book, and is very fair when it comes to pricing. He also knows the comic book market and is extremely knowledgeable in this field. I will continue to buy from him and his shop, and hope to find many more books through dealing with him. I highly recommend Guy and his shop.
Justin Ting
-
August 21, 2023
A pleasure to finally find this place thanks to my good friend Nick! Guy the owner is a treasure. His store is full of wonderful collectibles not to mention a nice open spacious parking lot. Never did I know I would find and come across a rare Akira Kurosawa film relic piece of actor Toshiro Mifune from the 1960 Yojimbo samurai film. The 1/6 figure is absolutely beautiful and a true Japanese made collectible. Guy also hooked me up with some awesome deals for comics books! Definitely had a grand day there ! Can't wait for my return! Guy I appreciate you so much!
Jason
-
March 08, 2025
Amazing store! Great selection of comics old and new. Owner is very nice and knowledgeable. Great experience 5 stars
John Cato
-
February 14, 2022
Quaint comicbook shop but big names and personalities held inside. I went to get some books signed by Al Milgrom and it was a blast.
Lots of different titles and collectibles. A must see The owner Guy.... Yes really his name is Guy treated his customers to a Marvel inspired cake!
ILoveBabylon
-
June 11, 2024
Check out All Star Comics in Lindenhurst, NY, run by the awesome Guy Schwartz! They've got a fantastic mix of new and classic comics in a super easy-to-browse layout. The owner and staff totally know their stuff. Plus, they've got cool plushies, awesome merch, and a fun video game. It's a blast for kids and anyone who loves a good story!
Our Address
200 E Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, USA
Claim Listing: All Star Comics & Collectibles
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I’ve been dealing with Guy at All Star Comics for the last couple of months, and I have to say that it’s been a pleasure to deal with him. He has helped me find certain silver age comics that I have been looking for to add to my collection. He has never pressured me to buy any book, and is very fair when it comes to pricing. He also knows the comic book market and is extremely knowledgeable in this field. I will continue to buy from him and his shop, and hope to find many more books through dealing with him. I highly recommend Guy and his shop.
A pleasure to finally find this place thanks to my good friend Nick! Guy the owner is a treasure. His store is full of wonderful collectibles not to mention a nice open spacious parking lot. Never did I know I would find and come across a rare Akira Kurosawa film relic piece of actor Toshiro Mifune from the 1960 Yojimbo samurai film. The 1/6 figure is absolutely beautiful and a true Japanese made collectible. Guy also hooked me up with some awesome deals for comics books! Definitely had a grand day there ! Can't wait for my return! Guy I appreciate you so much!
Amazing store! Great selection of comics old and new. Owner is very nice and knowledgeable. Great experience 5 stars
Quaint comicbook shop but big names and personalities held inside. I went to get some books signed by Al Milgrom and it was a blast. Lots of different titles and collectibles. A must see The owner Guy.... Yes really his name is Guy treated his customers to a Marvel inspired cake!
Check out All Star Comics in Lindenhurst, NY, run by the awesome Guy Schwartz! They've got a fantastic mix of new and classic comics in a super easy-to-browse layout. The owner and staff totally know their stuff. Plus, they've got cool plushies, awesome merch, and a fun video game. It's a blast for kids and anyone who loves a good story!