I had dinner at Argyle Grill & Tavern last night and I can confidently say this place exceeds expectations. From the moment we walked in, the experience was seamless. Although it was busy, we were seated right away, and the staff was incredibly accommodating when we requested a quieter table in the back once one became available.
The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance, lively and social near the bar in the front, with a more intimate dining area in the back for a relaxed meal.
We started with cocktails and they were 10/10 not only delicious but beautifully presented. For appetizers, we went with the tuna rice cakes (highly recommend!), the French onion soup, and were lucky enough to get a taste of the lobster bisque. The owner personally brought it out for us to try, and let me tell you… I’ll be ordering a full bowl next time. It was creamy, buttery, and bursting with flavor, pure comfort in a cup.
We also split a Caesar salad, which came perfectly chopped and lightly dressed, exactly how I like it. For entrees, we had the sea bass, the Gorgonzola strip steak, and the spicy stuffed rigatoni. Every dish was packed with flavor, plated beautifully, and cooked to perfection. We couldn’t help but share bites from each other’s plates because everything was that good.
From service to presentation, everything was top-notch. The menu is so well thought out, it’s honestly hard to choose so I’ll definitely be back to try more! The price reflects the quality, and in my opinion, it’s worth every penny.
Hands down the best dining experience in Babylon Village. You won’t be disappointed. They truly know what they’re doing here.
Rianna
-
April 10, 2025
Visited argyle under the new ownership and really happy with the entire experience! Food was super flavorful and delicious and we loved everything recommended by our server. The cocktail list was amazing and love that they kept the classic watermelon martini! Will definitely be returning to try other items on the menu!
Angry Panda
-
January 03, 2025
Today I visited for the first time since the reopening. Was blown away by the chicken panini special. My friend ordered the burger, he assures me that it's one of the best he's had. I'm not big on taking pictures of food, but there was a very cool brand on the bun. Keep up the good work fellas!
Kendra Dunn
-
May 31, 2025
I have had the BEST experience at the Argyle. I’ve been there twice: the brunch was out of this world. Brunch: I recommend the French toast and the Benedict!!!!!
For Dinner: any steak with sweet potato’s and Brussels! The Mac and cheese is also next level.
Dessert is unbeatable as well.. I recommend the snickers cheesecake and espresso martini!
They also had good specials.
I had dinner at Argyle Grill & Tavern last night and I can confidently say this place exceeds expectations. From the moment we walked in, the experience was seamless. Although it was busy, we were seated right away, and the staff was incredibly accommodating when we requested a quieter table in the back once one became available. The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance, lively and social near the bar in the front, with a more intimate dining area in the back for a relaxed meal. We started with cocktails and they were 10/10 not only delicious but beautifully presented. For appetizers, we went with the tuna rice cakes (highly recommend!), the French onion soup, and were lucky enough to get a taste of the lobster bisque. The owner personally brought it out for us to try, and let me tell you… I’ll be ordering a full bowl next time. It was creamy, buttery, and bursting with flavor, pure comfort in a cup. We also split a Caesar salad, which came perfectly chopped and lightly dressed, exactly how I like it. For entrees, we had the sea bass, the Gorgonzola strip steak, and the spicy stuffed rigatoni. Every dish was packed with flavor, plated beautifully, and cooked to perfection. We couldn’t help but share bites from each other’s plates because everything was that good. From service to presentation, everything was top-notch. The menu is so well thought out, it’s honestly hard to choose so I’ll definitely be back to try more! The price reflects the quality, and in my opinion, it’s worth every penny. Hands down the best dining experience in Babylon Village. You won’t be disappointed. They truly know what they’re doing here.
Visited argyle under the new ownership and really happy with the entire experience! Food was super flavorful and delicious and we loved everything recommended by our server. The cocktail list was amazing and love that they kept the classic watermelon martini! Will definitely be returning to try other items on the menu!
Today I visited for the first time since the reopening. Was blown away by the chicken panini special. My friend ordered the burger, he assures me that it's one of the best he's had. I'm not big on taking pictures of food, but there was a very cool brand on the bun. Keep up the good work fellas!
I have had the BEST experience at the Argyle. I’ve been there twice: the brunch was out of this world. Brunch: I recommend the French toast and the Benedict!!!!! For Dinner: any steak with sweet potato’s and Brussels! The Mac and cheese is also next level. Dessert is unbeatable as well.. I recommend the snickers cheesecake and espresso martini! They also had good specials.
My wife and I recently came in for a delightful evening. I ordered the steakhouse bacon from the weekly special menu, while my wife opted for the short rib. Both dishes were absolutely delicious! For dessert, we shared the passionfruit crème brûlée, which was the perfect sweet ending to our meal. Our waitress, Jen, was outstanding. She was helpful, attentive, and provided excellent recommendations that made our dining experience even better. I highly recommend the Argyle Grill and Tavern!