I made the best choice for our NYE Dinner, after the Argyle Theatre. The Staff were absolutely the the best hustling non-stop, polite & professional. The Manager was overseeing that all aspects of the restaurant were flowing flawlessly. Kudos to the Chef outstanding dishes. My Rib eye phenomenal
Angela LoMastro
-
December 08, 2025
Last night was my first time here and I will definitely be coming back. The night started off pretty rocky because of the long wait. I had a reservation for 8pm but didn't end up getting seated until almost 9 because of how busy it was and all the reservations being pushed back due to the street fair and lack of parking. Although we were frustrated it was understandable and the manager Joe went above and beyond to make sure we were well taken care of and totally made up for the wait! Our waiter Matt was also excellent and so helpful. The food was delicious and lived up to all the expectations.
Marvyn Blake
-
September 29, 2025
My wife and I enjoyed the service, they were friendly. We went on a Sunday, so we were happy to get parking. Food was a hit and miss. So were the drinks. The margarita was delicious and the short rib wellingtons were amazing. I would recommend giving this restaurant a try.
Michele Kunz
-
September 15, 2025
This place is amazing. Great service, drinks, and the food is awesome. Great weekday price- fixe meals. I had salmon and my husband had filet mignon. Appetizers and sides were the best!! Honestly. Jenn treated us like VIPs. Highly recommended. Can’t wait to go back!
Ray Cal
-
January 07, 2026
I went to the Argyle Grill tonight to celebrate my Birthday. We were a party of 12 and everyone raved about the food. I have to say, The food was awesome. Most of us did the Fixed price menu and we were not disappointed. There were plenty of selections to choose from and the servings were a good size. Our server Eddie and his crew did a fantastic job, they were attentive and made the night go smoothly. The manager Joe even stopped by to see how everything was going. I would definitely recommend checking this place out.
Our Address
90 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon, NY 11702, USA
Claim Listing: Argyle Grill & Tavern
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I made the best choice for our NYE Dinner, after the Argyle Theatre. The Staff were absolutely the the best hustling non-stop, polite & professional. The Manager was overseeing that all aspects of the restaurant were flowing flawlessly. Kudos to the Chef outstanding dishes. My Rib eye phenomenal
Last night was my first time here and I will definitely be coming back. The night started off pretty rocky because of the long wait. I had a reservation for 8pm but didn't end up getting seated until almost 9 because of how busy it was and all the reservations being pushed back due to the street fair and lack of parking. Although we were frustrated it was understandable and the manager Joe went above and beyond to make sure we were well taken care of and totally made up for the wait! Our waiter Matt was also excellent and so helpful. The food was delicious and lived up to all the expectations.
My wife and I enjoyed the service, they were friendly. We went on a Sunday, so we were happy to get parking. Food was a hit and miss. So were the drinks. The margarita was delicious and the short rib wellingtons were amazing. I would recommend giving this restaurant a try.
This place is amazing. Great service, drinks, and the food is awesome. Great weekday price- fixe meals. I had salmon and my husband had filet mignon. Appetizers and sides were the best!! Honestly. Jenn treated us like VIPs. Highly recommended. Can’t wait to go back!
I went to the Argyle Grill tonight to celebrate my Birthday. We were a party of 12 and everyone raved about the food. I have to say, The food was awesome. Most of us did the Fixed price menu and we were not disappointed. There were plenty of selections to choose from and the servings were a good size. Our server Eddie and his crew did a fantastic job, they were attentive and made the night go smoothly. The manager Joe even stopped by to see how everything was going. I would definitely recommend checking this place out.