A Diner is like a Restaurant but better, right?
Yep you can get anything you want at a diner, from eggs to shrimp francese to a Greek salad to pancakes...
lts amazing how a diner could make all this, such a variety but it has to affect the quality though imo.
Hence one less star for the prices on the menus (see pic's), "restaurant prices" are just too much for a "diner", imo.
However the burger was made quite good, and charred nicely!
The matzo ball soup (best value) was loaded up with two matzo balls, chicken, noodles veggies.
Our serve (Junior) was extra special. He was pleasant and made sure our food was as we ordered. This makes everything more enjoyable, all servers should be as kind! Ty.
Mimi W
-
May 18, 2025
It’s very nice diner we just were unlucky to be seated next to a large table of family with kids who were watching YouTube on full mode.
Our waiter was super tired and not helpful at all. (Didn’t mention that one of the dish is coming on a hot plate even though we came with a little kid) also when I asked if my dish comes with french fries he said yes but it didn’t.
James Wood
-
January 02, 2025
We came in New Year's Day for brunch, and it was a fantastic experience! Despite the busy holiday crowd, they were able to seat our party of eight in just about 20 minutes.
Our server was attentive and efficient, taking our drink orders right away and ensuring we had everything we needed. By the time our drinks arrived, he was already taking our food orders.
The food arrived not long after, piping hot and fresh. Every dish was absolutely delicious, and we enjoyed our meals.
I highly recommend Atlantis Diner!!
Kensuto
-
September 06, 2024
We made reservations and had 7 people in total (family and friends). Staff were nice enough to mix 2 tables into one so we can all fit and be comfortable. Took our orders quickly and food didn’t take too long to arrive. Oreo milkshake tasted good, my meal was alright.
Trish Lee
-
March 18, 2025
It has been a while since we've eaten here and this evening we were pleasantly reminded that we should drop in more often. The service was terrific. The restaurant was clean and had a pleasant ambiance. The food was tasty and the portions were big. There was one notable exception to the "tasty" food however . . .the "potato salad". From what we could see and taste, it seemed to contain olives, red skin potatoes, mayo, carrots, and red bell peppers. It's as if the chef had no idea what ingredients belong in potato salad. Order the fries instead.
Our Address
350 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795, USA
Claim Listing: Atlantis Diner
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
A Diner is like a Restaurant but better, right? Yep you can get anything you want at a diner, from eggs to shrimp francese to a Greek salad to pancakes... lts amazing how a diner could make all this, such a variety but it has to affect the quality though imo. Hence one less star for the prices on the menus (see pic's), "restaurant prices" are just too much for a "diner", imo. However the burger was made quite good, and charred nicely! The matzo ball soup (best value) was loaded up with two matzo balls, chicken, noodles veggies. Our serve (Junior) was extra special. He was pleasant and made sure our food was as we ordered. This makes everything more enjoyable, all servers should be as kind! Ty.
It’s very nice diner we just were unlucky to be seated next to a large table of family with kids who were watching YouTube on full mode. Our waiter was super tired and not helpful at all. (Didn’t mention that one of the dish is coming on a hot plate even though we came with a little kid) also when I asked if my dish comes with french fries he said yes but it didn’t.
We came in New Year's Day for brunch, and it was a fantastic experience! Despite the busy holiday crowd, they were able to seat our party of eight in just about 20 minutes. Our server was attentive and efficient, taking our drink orders right away and ensuring we had everything we needed. By the time our drinks arrived, he was already taking our food orders. The food arrived not long after, piping hot and fresh. Every dish was absolutely delicious, and we enjoyed our meals. I highly recommend Atlantis Diner!!
We made reservations and had 7 people in total (family and friends). Staff were nice enough to mix 2 tables into one so we can all fit and be comfortable. Took our orders quickly and food didn’t take too long to arrive. Oreo milkshake tasted good, my meal was alright.
It has been a while since we've eaten here and this evening we were pleasantly reminded that we should drop in more often. The service was terrific. The restaurant was clean and had a pleasant ambiance. The food was tasty and the portions were big. There was one notable exception to the "tasty" food however . . .the "potato salad". From what we could see and taste, it seemed to contain olives, red skin potatoes, mayo, carrots, and red bell peppers. It's as if the chef had no idea what ingredients belong in potato salad. Order the fries instead.