Atlantis Diner

350 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795, USA

About Atlantis Diner

4.2 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Rick White
    -
    June 17, 2023

    This was an interesting experience. Kudos to Theresa for serving me and making this review better. The food was very good, and I would eat here again. I must say the waitress assigned to my table never acknowledged me, apologized for making me wait and not serving me, or even checking on me. Theresa, a manager took care of me with great service. If you read this Theresa, thank you!!... 6/16/2023.. I returned to have super and after waiting 30 minutes without being acknowledged I left.

    Jennifer Magioncalda
    -
    August 20, 2023

    Great inside atmosphere. The Wait staff was very attentive. I went there specifically for the cheesecake shake because I heard it was delish. It did not disappoint.

    Melanie Marine
    -
    June 09, 2023

    I enjoy Atlantis Diner because they do have delicious food and I particularly enjoy their salads. However, I am not a huge fan of their service. I went once before and did not care for the way the manager spoke to me or the other staff. Then I went this week and also did not have a good experience. My cousin and I asked for plastic utensils as the ones on the table were not clean. This was thankfully provided to us but of course removed when we were done with our appetizers. Then when we accidentally asked for a plastic spoon for our entree, it was supplied. But when we asked if we can get a plastic fork as we previously made a mistake we were met with criticism from the waiter. He said something under his breath to the effect of, "Oh now you want a fork? You're doing real good." This bothered us because one it was an honest mistake that did not warrant criticism and two we didn't think it was a big deal or request especially since we ordered salads. We love the food here but the service can definitely use some improvement. Until then we may just order out but we would love to come back once the service is a little better which would improve our overall experience. Also I would like to add that Danny the busboy is a phenomenal person and we were very pleased with his helpful service.

    MajestyNine
    -
    August 20, 2023

    The diner was nice. The atmosphere was quiet. The drinks were well made. A little pricey but you pay for the area. Waffles were great home fries were the best! I've had in a long time.

    Michael M
    -
    August 05, 2023

    I really enjoyed this diner! The food I had was great (Philly Cheesesteak), the staff were attentive, and the food got to the table rather quickly! I also enjoyed the cheesecake slice I had. Not too expensive, either!

    Atlantis Diner

    Our Address

    350 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795, USA

    Join the ONLY Babylon Town Website for All of Us!

    Would you like to add your Business or Organization to our site? It’s FREE!  Click the button to get started now >>