Atlantis Diner

350 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795, USA

About Atlantis Diner

4.2 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Sonya Williams
    July 01, 2024

    We took a party of 9 to Atlantis on Sunday after church. Service was fast and the food was delicious. Pancakes are wonderful! Our server was kind and super attentive. A lot of us Even had enough food to take home. Very good visit

    Rick White
    June 17, 2023

    This was an interesting experience. Kudos to Theresa for serving me and making this review better. The food was very good, and I would eat here again. I must say the waitress assigned to my table never acknowledged me, apologized for making me wait and not serving me, or even checking on me. Theresa, a manager took care of me with great service. If you read this Theresa, thank you!!... 6/16/2023.. I returned to have super and after waiting 30 minutes without being acknowledged I left.

    Glider RS
    February 28, 2024

    Small diner near Bay Shore. Went for a business lunch and the service was fast and food was decent.

    Sheleeza Peters
    July 09, 2024

    What a great and purifying atmosphere …Our waitress was so polite and good sense of humor .She served us with a beautiful smile .. what a beautiful place to dine .Keep up the good job Laura .

    Henry C
    May 11, 2024

    We go to diners often and for the most part have had really good experiences except in Atlantis Diner. It actually was a HORRIBLE experience from the moment we walked in. We asked to be seated in a booth because my back was out and I did not want to sit against a wooden chair and the hostess actually seemed annoyed and grunted. Then when we placed our order I asked for my bacon deep fried, very well done and crispy because I can not eat chewy bacon, our food came and it was EXACTLY how I did not want. I asked the waiter if he could redo the bacon and he responded " no, I can not waste food " . I was shocked that he refused to take it back and insisted that it was fine. Eventually the hostess came over and forced him to redo the bacon. As a paying customer our food should be given to us the way we ask and want, if it isn't correct they should redo it with no issues. I DO NOT recommend this place due to the staffs poor attitude and unfortunately I can not comment on quality of food because we wound up not eating and leaving because I was so angry.

    Atlantis Diner

    Our Address

    350 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795, USA

    Join the ONLY Babylon Town Website for All of Us!

    Would you like to add your Business or Organization to our site? It’s FREE!  Click the button to get started now >>