Stumbled onto this place completely by accident. My daughter and I ordered 1 garlic knot slice each. Owner was supper nice and friendly. The place was clean and cute and the pizza was AMAZING. Definitely will recommend and come back.
A A
-
August 19, 2025
Bella Pazza makes a great pizza consistently.
A nice, family run establishment.
We’ve been impressed with the pizza every visit this summer. He makes a great pie that has brought us back time and again. This time we got the garlic knot pie that I’ve been eyeing since I saw it on the menu. I didn’t have enough patience to photograph before digging in, but I posted a photo of what was left over. This was an awesome creation.
Not every pizzeria in the area makes good food. They know how to make good food here. The dough is the right thinness, the sauce is great, and they get the crust-sauce-cheese ratio correct. If the website is true in that they don’t use brominated flour, that’s the “icing on the cake.” I’ve been eating pizza in the Babylon/West Islip/Bay Shore area for 30 years and now when my family wants pizza takeout, we have to get it from Bella Pazza.
Caitlin Bella
-
October 19, 2025
The most amazing place the food was incredible and so fresh my pizza & garlic knots!! The owner and the family were extremely friendly will definitely be my go to pizzeria for now on!
Жеремей Сенько
-
January 03, 2025
Its been a while since I've been through.
Fantastic slices, definitely coming back again! Owner is super friendly and has excellent relationships with customers! One of my favourite joints for sure.
Next time I have to try the upside down ! ))
Rafael Ferrigno
-
August 26, 2025
The best pizza in Babylon! They use high-quality, organic ingredients. Aldo and his family truly deserve ten stars for their care, love, and kindness. I love the pizza and the family!
Our Address
258 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon, NY 11702, USA
Claim Listing: Bella Pazza Pizzeria
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Stumbled onto this place completely by accident. My daughter and I ordered 1 garlic knot slice each. Owner was supper nice and friendly. The place was clean and cute and the pizza was AMAZING. Definitely will recommend and come back.
Bella Pazza makes a great pizza consistently. A nice, family run establishment. We’ve been impressed with the pizza every visit this summer. He makes a great pie that has brought us back time and again. This time we got the garlic knot pie that I’ve been eyeing since I saw it on the menu. I didn’t have enough patience to photograph before digging in, but I posted a photo of what was left over. This was an awesome creation. Not every pizzeria in the area makes good food. They know how to make good food here. The dough is the right thinness, the sauce is great, and they get the crust-sauce-cheese ratio correct. If the website is true in that they don’t use brominated flour, that’s the “icing on the cake.” I’ve been eating pizza in the Babylon/West Islip/Bay Shore area for 30 years and now when my family wants pizza takeout, we have to get it from Bella Pazza.
The most amazing place the food was incredible and so fresh my pizza & garlic knots!! The owner and the family were extremely friendly will definitely be my go to pizzeria for now on!
Its been a while since I've been through. Fantastic slices, definitely coming back again! Owner is super friendly and has excellent relationships with customers! One of my favourite joints for sure. Next time I have to try the upside down ! ))
The best pizza in Babylon! They use high-quality, organic ingredients. Aldo and his family truly deserve ten stars for their care, love, and kindness. I love the pizza and the family!