The absolute best place for pizza on the island. Try their old fashioned slice. They make it just like you get it from Sicily. The breadcrumbs sautéed onions. The sauce and dough is delicious!!!!!
Marvin Fuentes
-
June 09, 2025
Hands down the best pizzeria in the Babylon area. Try the shrimp pesto pizza and their chicken bacon ranch is out of this world. And Leo’s the man; been coming here for years and he’s always helpful
Tai Vicari
-
May 10, 2025
Wow, from food to service😋😍. The owner and chef Salvatore and his team are just so welcoming. Thank you, Jill and Lucas for being excellent and making our Luncheon perfect. You both were extremely attentive and accommodating with our special requests.
The food was delicious. I had the stuffed flounder with linguini and the stuffing was a delicious shrimp and bread stuffing so so good👍😋
Some had the Chicken Parmigiano and others the Chicken Francese and all was loved. But what stood out was the delicious addictive house dressing on the salad. Yeah, I took a garlic knot to sop it up it was. 😉
Thank you all for a great Luncheon experience.
Joe
-
April 27, 2025
It bewilders me how they serve a chicken parm hero with no sauce. I know they didn’t run out of sauce because we also got a shrimp parm hero and it came with some sauce on it. And they have the nerve to charge for extra sauce as in a side order. This order I went and picked up knowing they only use very little sauce and when I get it delivered they never include the extra sauce I ask for in the comments. Makes the hero very dry. So this order I picked up and also ordered the “side” of extra sauce for $1.50. Lucky I did or I would’ve thrown my chicken parm in the trash. Zero sauce on it what a joke. It’s a “side” of sauce not sauce on the side lol. Better place down the road.
Steven Surico
-
September 19, 2025
Cafe Gio
📍West Babylon, NY
@cafegio_restaurant
Cafe Gio in West Babylon has been a staple in the community since 1994, serving up some amazing Italian dishes. Great pizza and food is the reason why it’s been able to survive over 30 years! We absolutely loved everything we got here and the service was incredible. This is a great spot for date night, a meal with the whole family, or a quick lunch bite. Come check them out!
Follow us on Instagram @drinklongislandny for full video review and many more spots!
Our Address
761 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA
Claim Listing: Cafe Gio
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
The absolute best place for pizza on the island. Try their old fashioned slice. They make it just like you get it from Sicily. The breadcrumbs sautéed onions. The sauce and dough is delicious!!!!!
Hands down the best pizzeria in the Babylon area. Try the shrimp pesto pizza and their chicken bacon ranch is out of this world. And Leo’s the man; been coming here for years and he’s always helpful
Wow, from food to service😋😍. The owner and chef Salvatore and his team are just so welcoming. Thank you, Jill and Lucas for being excellent and making our Luncheon perfect. You both were extremely attentive and accommodating with our special requests. The food was delicious. I had the stuffed flounder with linguini and the stuffing was a delicious shrimp and bread stuffing so so good👍😋 Some had the Chicken Parmigiano and others the Chicken Francese and all was loved. But what stood out was the delicious addictive house dressing on the salad. Yeah, I took a garlic knot to sop it up it was. 😉 Thank you all for a great Luncheon experience.
It bewilders me how they serve a chicken parm hero with no sauce. I know they didn’t run out of sauce because we also got a shrimp parm hero and it came with some sauce on it. And they have the nerve to charge for extra sauce as in a side order. This order I went and picked up knowing they only use very little sauce and when I get it delivered they never include the extra sauce I ask for in the comments. Makes the hero very dry. So this order I picked up and also ordered the “side” of extra sauce for $1.50. Lucky I did or I would’ve thrown my chicken parm in the trash. Zero sauce on it what a joke. It’s a “side” of sauce not sauce on the side lol. Better place down the road.
Cafe Gio 📍West Babylon, NY @cafegio_restaurant Cafe Gio in West Babylon has been a staple in the community since 1994, serving up some amazing Italian dishes. Great pizza and food is the reason why it’s been able to survive over 30 years! We absolutely loved everything we got here and the service was incredible. This is a great spot for date night, a meal with the whole family, or a quick lunch bite. Come check them out! Follow us on Instagram @drinklongislandny for full video review and many more spots!