I recommend this place and would give 10 stars if I could. I got into an accident and my insurance sent me to this place. They provided me with a rental and had my car fixed in under 10 days. They also detailed my car in and out before giving it back to me. Staff is super friendly and very helpful.
Alex Barone
-
February 17, 2026
Brought car there after an accident. Based on the damage, was expecting at least 3 - 4 weeks b4 it was repaired. I had it back in 8 days. They did excellent work. Everything looks great and feels great. The office was very kind and caring as well. Would definitely recommend and use again.
Alex M
-
January 23, 2026
Outstanding experience from start to finish. The team was professional, honest, and kept me informed throughout the entire process. They negotiated with the insurance company on my behalf, which made everything stress-free. The quality of the repair was excellent! My car looks brand new, solid turnaround time and truly great customer service. Highly recommend!
Mohammed Rahman
-
January 30, 2026
Nice people, new management is good. My car took longer than a month to repair, and the insurance stopped paying for the rental. They paid $400 towards my rental cost, which was as good as waiving the deductible. They did a good job with the repair work and even had me come back for the air-conditioning pipe, which was unavailable when the car was released. I highly recommend this place.
Peter Ponce-Toriz
-
December 29, 2025
I can now legally leave this review. My car was stolen OUT OF THEIR LOT. They left the keys to my car IN THE CAR AND UNLOCKED. People came and clipped their lock (and somehow they didn’t notice in the morning) and took my car. They didn’t even know it was missing until I came to try and pick it up. They were apparently uncooperative with police in getting the security footage to them. They also somehow found the 5 minutes worth of footage over a whole nights worth of footage in a manner of seconds. Very fishy over all. Sketchy place. Don’t bring your car here.
Our Address
13a Lucon Dr, Deer Park, NY 11729, USA
Claim Listing: CARSTAR Island Automotive and Collision
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I recommend this place and would give 10 stars if I could. I got into an accident and my insurance sent me to this place. They provided me with a rental and had my car fixed in under 10 days. They also detailed my car in and out before giving it back to me. Staff is super friendly and very helpful.
Brought car there after an accident. Based on the damage, was expecting at least 3 - 4 weeks b4 it was repaired. I had it back in 8 days. They did excellent work. Everything looks great and feels great. The office was very kind and caring as well. Would definitely recommend and use again.
Outstanding experience from start to finish. The team was professional, honest, and kept me informed throughout the entire process. They negotiated with the insurance company on my behalf, which made everything stress-free. The quality of the repair was excellent! My car looks brand new, solid turnaround time and truly great customer service. Highly recommend!
Nice people, new management is good. My car took longer than a month to repair, and the insurance stopped paying for the rental. They paid $400 towards my rental cost, which was as good as waiving the deductible. They did a good job with the repair work and even had me come back for the air-conditioning pipe, which was unavailable when the car was released. I highly recommend this place.
I can now legally leave this review. My car was stolen OUT OF THEIR LOT. They left the keys to my car IN THE CAR AND UNLOCKED. People came and clipped their lock (and somehow they didn’t notice in the morning) and took my car. They didn’t even know it was missing until I came to try and pick it up. They were apparently uncooperative with police in getting the security footage to them. They also somehow found the 5 minutes worth of footage over a whole nights worth of footage in a manner of seconds. Very fishy over all. Sketchy place. Don’t bring your car here.