3-Star Review
Very nice place with a lot of potential, and I genuinely wish I could give a five-star review as I usually do. Unfortunately, the lack of communication—both with customers and internally between staff—is the reason for my lower rating.
I placed a special order almost a month ago and have been getting the runaround ever since. I visited in person to place the order, followed up with a phone call to confirm, and asked multiple times if a deposit was needed. Each time, I was met with uncertainty and no clear answer.
The staff is friendly, but the communication gaps are frustrating and have led to unnecessary delays. I hope they work on streamlining their internal processes because the customer experience could be much better with just a bit more follow-through.
Karen Baynes
-
August 31, 2025
The worker who is more than likely the owner was polite, attentive and helped me pick this brand of Moscato being 1% more added alcohol with a sample of the black berry brand... STRONG... I'm in the house for the rest of the evening 🙌
Deedie Roze
-
December 10, 2022
This liquor store gives liquor tastings every Friday or Saturday evening from 5p to 8p. Call to confirm. Today I sampled Black Irish. I asked for the barista to combine White Chocolate with the Original flavor because I did not like the original by itself. White Chocolate added body to the Original, so the combination tasted magnificent! The Salted Caramel flavor was too sweet for my blood!
I will be back next week for another liquor tasting.
Gursagar Singh
-
August 20, 2025
I’ve always passed by Crazy Billys since I live close by and went wine shopping here a long time ago so I decided to revisit. Boy was I shocked by how much they’re looting their customers! Wine’s and Spirits are WAY OVERPRICED! I do all my shopping in Central Islip at my buddy’s liquor store so I’m always comparing at new places. Passing off some $6 wines for $15 and bottom barrel chamoagnes for $12-$15 is highway robbery (and yes I buy the same items for that much cheaper in CI). I would call nearby stores and go the extra mile than spend my money here. It’s called crazy billys because you’ve got to be out of your mind to go here.
I will say though I was really impressed by the organization and displays!
Kimberly Oswald
-
March 26, 2024
Employees so super helpful, educated, and so sweet.
Steered us to what we needed and taught us about some differences in different types of tequilla, vodka, and moonshines. Turned us on old smokey sour moonshines watermelon and sour berry equal parts make a sour kid shot. Omg. So good.
Our Address
1887 Deer Pk Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729, USA
Claim Listing: Crazy Billy’s Fine Wine & Spirits
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
3-Star Review Very nice place with a lot of potential, and I genuinely wish I could give a five-star review as I usually do. Unfortunately, the lack of communication—both with customers and internally between staff—is the reason for my lower rating. I placed a special order almost a month ago and have been getting the runaround ever since. I visited in person to place the order, followed up with a phone call to confirm, and asked multiple times if a deposit was needed. Each time, I was met with uncertainty and no clear answer. The staff is friendly, but the communication gaps are frustrating and have led to unnecessary delays. I hope they work on streamlining their internal processes because the customer experience could be much better with just a bit more follow-through.
The worker who is more than likely the owner was polite, attentive and helped me pick this brand of Moscato being 1% more added alcohol with a sample of the black berry brand... STRONG... I'm in the house for the rest of the evening 🙌
This liquor store gives liquor tastings every Friday or Saturday evening from 5p to 8p. Call to confirm. Today I sampled Black Irish. I asked for the barista to combine White Chocolate with the Original flavor because I did not like the original by itself. White Chocolate added body to the Original, so the combination tasted magnificent! The Salted Caramel flavor was too sweet for my blood! I will be back next week for another liquor tasting.
I’ve always passed by Crazy Billys since I live close by and went wine shopping here a long time ago so I decided to revisit. Boy was I shocked by how much they’re looting their customers! Wine’s and Spirits are WAY OVERPRICED! I do all my shopping in Central Islip at my buddy’s liquor store so I’m always comparing at new places. Passing off some $6 wines for $15 and bottom barrel chamoagnes for $12-$15 is highway robbery (and yes I buy the same items for that much cheaper in CI). I would call nearby stores and go the extra mile than spend my money here. It’s called crazy billys because you’ve got to be out of your mind to go here. I will say though I was really impressed by the organization and displays!
Employees so super helpful, educated, and so sweet. Steered us to what we needed and taught us about some differences in different types of tequilla, vodka, and moonshines. Turned us on old smokey sour moonshines watermelon and sour berry equal parts make a sour kid shot. Omg. So good.