Gemelli Fine Foods

115 E Main St, Babylon, NY 11702, USA

About Gemelli Fine Foods

4.5 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Aleks
    -
    May 07, 2023

    0 stars if possible. We paid almost $15 each for these. Tiny portions high prices. My hero isnt even covered. Dont go here. Will never go back. You seriously call yourselfs Italian?

    Sean Fay
    -
    January 03, 2025

    Catered food for Christmas and everyone enjoyed people working there are awesome too

    Matthew Matt
    -
    December 25, 2022

    Very disappointed we ordered over $400 worth of catered food several trays. The food tasted horrible everyone Christmas Eve was complaining including myself. The chicken parmesan was just chunks of chicken thrown in a pan with sauce and mozzarella as if the whole thing was rushed It was not like traditional chicken parmesan with clean pieces of breaded chicken done with care with mozzarella and sauce. And the overall taste didn't even taste good. The sausage and peppers didn't taste good at all The sausage tasted like they were microwaved with that funny aftertaste. The other trays of food that we ordered didn't taste good either not going to go on. We've always had catered food from other places never where we this disappointed. I hate to give them a bad review but I'm sure I'm not going to be the only one since I heard they had several hundred orders. I would never go back there again. I understand they may have been really busy but not acceptable. If I had a guess maybe they had a bunch of kids pitching in to throw the stuff together quickly that's how bad it tasted. I'm curious if others will chime in

    Will Lovelock
    -
    December 04, 2023

    Are you kidding? $12.99 + tax for 3 slices of roast beef thinly sliced on a roll? Should be ashamed. As a Babylon village resident, this will be the last time I go here.

    Robert Schwarz
    -
    November 17, 2024

    One of the best Italian provision stores on the South Shore of Long Island. Plenty of Italian delicacies to choose from including fresh pastas, sausages, meatballs and salads. Meats are excellent including pork, chicken and steak. Italian hero’s are fantastic. Worth the visit if in the Babylon village area.

    Aleks
    -
    May 07, 2023

    0 stars if possible. We paid almost $15 each for these. Tiny portions high prices. My hero isnt even covered. Dont go here. Will never go back. You seriously call yourselfs Italian?

    Sean Fay
    -
    January 03, 2025

    Catered food for Christmas and everyone enjoyed people working there are awesome too

    Matthew Matt
    -
    December 25, 2022

    Very disappointed we ordered over $400 worth of catered food several trays. The food tasted horrible everyone Christmas Eve was complaining including myself. The chicken parmesan was just chunks of chicken thrown in a pan with sauce and mozzarella as if the whole thing was rushed It was not like traditional chicken parmesan with clean pieces of breaded chicken done with care with mozzarella and sauce. And the overall taste didn't even taste good. The sausage and peppers didn't taste good at all The sausage tasted like they were microwaved with that funny aftertaste. The other trays of food that we ordered didn't taste good either not going to go on. We've always had catered food from other places never where we this disappointed. I hate to give them a bad review but I'm sure I'm not going to be the only one since I heard they had several hundred orders. I would never go back there again. I understand they may have been really busy but not acceptable. If I had a guess maybe they had a bunch of kids pitching in to throw the stuff together quickly that's how bad it tasted. I'm curious if others will chime in

    Will Lovelock
    -
    December 04, 2023

    Are you kidding? $12.99 + tax for 3 slices of roast beef thinly sliced on a roll? Should be ashamed. As a Babylon village resident, this will be the last time I go here.

    Robert Schwarz
    -
    November 17, 2024

    One of the best Italian provision stores on the South Shore of Long Island. Plenty of Italian delicacies to choose from including fresh pastas, sausages, meatballs and salads. Meats are excellent including pork, chicken and steak. Italian hero’s are fantastic. Worth the visit if in the Babylon village area.

    Aleks
    -
    May 07, 2023

    0 stars if possible. We paid almost $15 each for these. Tiny portions high prices. My hero isnt even covered. Dont go here. Will never go back. You seriously call yourselfs Italian?

    <
    >

    Our Address

    115 E Main St, Babylon, NY 11702, USA

    Join the ONLY Babylon Town Website for All of Us!

    Would you like to add your Business or Organization to our site? It’s FREE!  Click the button to get started now >>