This Gino’s is wonderful Pete and John are great. Love coming here with my son can’t go wrong with the regular slice or a specialty slice. The dinners are amazing if you have the opportunity to use the back dining room very reasonably priced to book a party. They even have an excellent dessert selection can’t go wrong with the gelato either.
Eric Martin
-
August 13, 2024
The food here is always good and the workers are very friendly.
However, my 3 star food rating is because the seasoning shakers are disgusting. I had to try 4 different garlic powder shakers until I found one that had a head that wasn't gooked up to the point where seasoning won't even cover out. It seems like they haven't been cleaned in ages. If they can't clean simple things like seasoning shakers it makes me question the sanitary state of the kitchen.
There was also a fly crawling around on one of the pinwheels. A little grossed out, but apparently not grossed out enough to not eat the pizza I got.
Please clean your shakers.
Luke Cometti
-
February 07, 2025
I’m from upstate and visit this area to see my in-laws. Tried this place for the first time, and hands down, these are the best Buffalo wings I’ve had around here. The Grandma pizza and the sausage and onion pizza were just as good as any I’ve had anywhere. This will definitely be our new go-to spot for takeout!
Justin Himes
-
January 28, 2023
Dont bother. Ordered lunch today. $21+ for a plate of plain pasta with red sauce and some melted cheese. I paid $5 for meat sauce and of course it wasn't a scrap of meat in it. Also what baked zitti on gods green earth doesn't have ricotta in it already? I saw the $3 surcharge and assumed it must be for extra because it isnt baked zitti without ricotta to start and its priced like other places zitti with ricotta. Every other restaurant in the area requires you to remove ricotta if you dont want it. I rarely come out swinging on reviews and leave 1 star, but this one had me fuming. Expensive lunch for a childrens menu style item.
Greg H
-
August 25, 2024
Ordered Pie over phone when Picked up they said it just came out.I have been in the business over 40 years I know reheated Pizza that's burned on bottom and also the cheese.This isn't the first time Horrible Pizza. Bye Geno's.Should be ashamed of yourselves this isn't the first or second time for me.
Our Address
90 NY-109, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA
Claim Listing: Gino’s Pizza of West Babylon
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
This Gino’s is wonderful Pete and John are great. Love coming here with my son can’t go wrong with the regular slice or a specialty slice. The dinners are amazing if you have the opportunity to use the back dining room very reasonably priced to book a party. They even have an excellent dessert selection can’t go wrong with the gelato either.
The food here is always good and the workers are very friendly. However, my 3 star food rating is because the seasoning shakers are disgusting. I had to try 4 different garlic powder shakers until I found one that had a head that wasn't gooked up to the point where seasoning won't even cover out. It seems like they haven't been cleaned in ages. If they can't clean simple things like seasoning shakers it makes me question the sanitary state of the kitchen. There was also a fly crawling around on one of the pinwheels. A little grossed out, but apparently not grossed out enough to not eat the pizza I got. Please clean your shakers.
I’m from upstate and visit this area to see my in-laws. Tried this place for the first time, and hands down, these are the best Buffalo wings I’ve had around here. The Grandma pizza and the sausage and onion pizza were just as good as any I’ve had anywhere. This will definitely be our new go-to spot for takeout!
Dont bother. Ordered lunch today. $21+ for a plate of plain pasta with red sauce and some melted cheese. I paid $5 for meat sauce and of course it wasn't a scrap of meat in it. Also what baked zitti on gods green earth doesn't have ricotta in it already? I saw the $3 surcharge and assumed it must be for extra because it isnt baked zitti without ricotta to start and its priced like other places zitti with ricotta. Every other restaurant in the area requires you to remove ricotta if you dont want it. I rarely come out swinging on reviews and leave 1 star, but this one had me fuming. Expensive lunch for a childrens menu style item.
Ordered Pie over phone when Picked up they said it just came out.I have been in the business over 40 years I know reheated Pizza that's burned on bottom and also the cheese.This isn't the first time Horrible Pizza. Bye Geno's.Should be ashamed of yourselves this isn't the first or second time for me.