I saw on their website that their wings were fresh, never frozen, so I was looking forward to trying them along with a specialty pizza. I picked up my order, brought it home, and found the wings dry, hard, and looking like yesterday’s batch—not sure, but definitely not fresh.
I called, sincerely asking for a refund on just the wings.
The response? “Bring them back.” No apology, no real concern. Mind you, I live 30 minutes away. The thought of driving all that way just to return eight wings was enough to make me write this review.
Here are your wings back, sir
J Alvarez
-
October 06, 2023
Get off of work at 9 PM, where can I get a great pasta dish? At Giovanni’s Pizza. Plenty of garlic in my FraDiavlo, And my pasta was al dente. Perfect. Thanks, Frank
Dan M
-
March 18, 2025
One time i ordered it was good, another time the dough was old and they still used it. Shame because in lindenhurst and babylon i would say this is the best pizza, but how can you eat old food?
Mikey Laterza jr
-
July 23, 2024
I go here every time I'm near the area . This instantly became my favorite pizza place, on long Island the first time I tried it . BEST PIZZA ON LONG ISLAND!
Deepi Kaur
-
April 10, 2024
Thick slices - very generous with the cheese.
I personally prefer more sauce than cheese, but if you are a cheese lover - you would love the cheese slices.
Our Address
1009 Little E Neck Rd, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA
Claim Listing: Giovanni’s Pizza
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I saw on their website that their wings were fresh, never frozen, so I was looking forward to trying them along with a specialty pizza. I picked up my order, brought it home, and found the wings dry, hard, and looking like yesterday’s batch—not sure, but definitely not fresh. I called, sincerely asking for a refund on just the wings. The response? “Bring them back.” No apology, no real concern. Mind you, I live 30 minutes away. The thought of driving all that way just to return eight wings was enough to make me write this review. Here are your wings back, sir
Get off of work at 9 PM, where can I get a great pasta dish? At Giovanni’s Pizza. Plenty of garlic in my FraDiavlo, And my pasta was al dente. Perfect. Thanks, Frank
One time i ordered it was good, another time the dough was old and they still used it. Shame because in lindenhurst and babylon i would say this is the best pizza, but how can you eat old food?
I go here every time I'm near the area . This instantly became my favorite pizza place, on long Island the first time I tried it . BEST PIZZA ON LONG ISLAND!
Thick slices - very generous with the cheese. I personally prefer more sauce than cheese, but if you are a cheese lover - you would love the cheese slices.