I don’t play card games like I use to, but if I did, Gotham would be a place I’d see myself coming to on a weekly (or at least monthly) basis. Walking into a card shop, I remember the immediate smell of B.O stench. Even after all these years. Thankfully Gotham doesn’t have it. The store is on the smaller side and thus it can feel a bit cluttered inside but the owner is nice and welcoming, they offer a showcase for the top card games for players to purchase, and have a wide assortment of booster boxes and accessories. The bathroom was clean. Prices were fair. If you’re a regular card game player or looking to get into one in a smaller setting I’d seriously consider this spot.
Donnie Ripz
-
May 31, 2025
Hands down the Best place to get Cards on Long island! Bobby the owner went above and beyond for my 2 friends with Destined Rivals. Genuine guy and great prices. He is really for the community. Will happily do business with him again and send more people here over deer park. Check out the store and you won't be disappointed👍🏻
Jennifer Valdez
-
July 18, 2025
Really amazing shop! The owners/staff are super friendly and very welcoming. Lots of cool product! Definitely recommend coming here!
Jonathan Sanchez
-
May 13, 2025
Gotham City Hobbies in West Babylon is a great local card shop!
Bob and Mike are awesome—super friendly and always helpful. The shop has a great variety of cards, and their prices are very reasonable compared to other card stores on Long Island. I’d definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a solid hobby shop with good vibes and fair prices.
TheOnePhoenix
-
July 06, 2025
I don’t want to sound like I’m saying the usual card shop stereotypes but it was extremely smelly inside and no room to really play and walk around especially if it’s crowded. The employee I had was very rude and felt like he didn’t even want to do his job. Overprices basic cards and won’t negotiate on deals. If you want to go to a better card shop go to nearly anywhere else
Our Address
70 NY-109, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA
Claim Listing: Gotham City / BattleCityGym
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I don’t play card games like I use to, but if I did, Gotham would be a place I’d see myself coming to on a weekly (or at least monthly) basis. Walking into a card shop, I remember the immediate smell of B.O stench. Even after all these years. Thankfully Gotham doesn’t have it. The store is on the smaller side and thus it can feel a bit cluttered inside but the owner is nice and welcoming, they offer a showcase for the top card games for players to purchase, and have a wide assortment of booster boxes and accessories. The bathroom was clean. Prices were fair. If you’re a regular card game player or looking to get into one in a smaller setting I’d seriously consider this spot.
Hands down the Best place to get Cards on Long island! Bobby the owner went above and beyond for my 2 friends with Destined Rivals. Genuine guy and great prices. He is really for the community. Will happily do business with him again and send more people here over deer park. Check out the store and you won't be disappointed👍🏻
Really amazing shop! The owners/staff are super friendly and very welcoming. Lots of cool product! Definitely recommend coming here!
Gotham City Hobbies in West Babylon is a great local card shop! Bob and Mike are awesome—super friendly and always helpful. The shop has a great variety of cards, and their prices are very reasonable compared to other card stores on Long Island. I’d definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a solid hobby shop with good vibes and fair prices.
I don’t want to sound like I’m saying the usual card shop stereotypes but it was extremely smelly inside and no room to really play and walk around especially if it’s crowded. The employee I had was very rude and felt like he didn’t even want to do his job. Overprices basic cards and won’t negotiate on deals. If you want to go to a better card shop go to nearly anywhere else