I don’t play card games like I use to, but if I did, Gotham would be a place I’d see myself coming to on a weekly (or at least monthly) basis. Walking into a card shop, I remember the immediate smell of B.O stench. Even after all these years. Thankfully Gotham doesn’t have it. The store is on the smaller side and thus it can feel a bit cluttered inside but the owner is nice and welcoming, they offer a showcase for the top card games for players to purchase, and have a wide assortment of booster boxes and accessories. The bathroom was clean. Prices were fair. If you’re a regular card game player or looking to get into one in a smaller setting I’d seriously consider this spot.
Anthony Buscaino
-
November 11, 2025
Mike and Bob do a great job serving the community. Play multiple locals here for various card games. Been supporting this stores for years. Pricing has always been fair.
Larry Johnson
-
November 18, 2025
I'm so sorry I have to do this but it needs to be said. Usually the new TCG sets that come out are fairly priced. However, I’m not sure what happened with the new pokemon Phantasmal flames release. I’ve purchased TCG sets here on multiple occasions, again prices were reasonable and affordable. This time, I’m not sure what happened but the prices were close to TCG market. The community loves to support small stores, but that was a blatant slap in the face. Myself as well as multiple collectors and players are turning in the opposite direction when it comes to this store. What happened? Maybe management needs a change?
Maya
-
November 15, 2025
This is my favorite card shop ever. I am always so well taken care of, prices are always amazing, the employees are always willing to make a great deal and have an amazing conversation. Such a great environment!
Brian Besmer
-
November 19, 2025
Been coming here for years! Great local store! Tons of Pokemon! Good amount of MtG! The run weekly events regularly! Strongly recommend you stop in!
Our Address
70 NY-109, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA
Claim Listing: Gotham City Hobbies Games & Collectibles
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I don’t play card games like I use to, but if I did, Gotham would be a place I’d see myself coming to on a weekly (or at least monthly) basis. Walking into a card shop, I remember the immediate smell of B.O stench. Even after all these years. Thankfully Gotham doesn’t have it. The store is on the smaller side and thus it can feel a bit cluttered inside but the owner is nice and welcoming, they offer a showcase for the top card games for players to purchase, and have a wide assortment of booster boxes and accessories. The bathroom was clean. Prices were fair. If you’re a regular card game player or looking to get into one in a smaller setting I’d seriously consider this spot.
Mike and Bob do a great job serving the community. Play multiple locals here for various card games. Been supporting this stores for years. Pricing has always been fair.
I'm so sorry I have to do this but it needs to be said. Usually the new TCG sets that come out are fairly priced. However, I’m not sure what happened with the new pokemon Phantasmal flames release. I’ve purchased TCG sets here on multiple occasions, again prices were reasonable and affordable. This time, I’m not sure what happened but the prices were close to TCG market. The community loves to support small stores, but that was a blatant slap in the face. Myself as well as multiple collectors and players are turning in the opposite direction when it comes to this store. What happened? Maybe management needs a change?
This is my favorite card shop ever. I am always so well taken care of, prices are always amazing, the employees are always willing to make a great deal and have an amazing conversation. Such a great environment!
Been coming here for years! Great local store! Tons of Pokemon! Good amount of MtG! The run weekly events regularly! Strongly recommend you stop in!