Hunter and Thief is truly a home away from home. From elevated comfort food to the welcoming, attentive staff, it’s the perfect spot whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a night of catching up with friends. The modern cocktail bar showcases an impressive lineup of drinks, and owner Jonathan consistently goes above and beyond to deliver twists on classics. And the food? It never disappoints. I’ve sampled nearly everything on their seasonally rotating menu and have been impressed time and time again. Standout favorites include the signature burger, the chopped cheese, the poutine, ricotta toast, and the calamari. As someone who has worked in the service industry, I can truthfully say this place is unlike any other and it will continue to have my business.
Betzally Mendoza
-
November 28, 2025
Been hosting my reading parties at Hunter & Thief since the summer. Amazing drinks & food! The staff is the best and always very welcoming. TRY THEIR CORNBREAD! I’m obsessed. :)
Robert RKNY26 (PresRKNY)
-
May 05, 2025
We went into this place the other day during the Lindenhurst Spring Fest and have to say that the atmosphere, food, and service was absolutely amazing. Although I didn’t get pictures of the food I assure you it was all delicious and well presented. The burger was seasoned perfectly and the chopped cheese sandwich was amazing. The corn bread was so good it would have even made for a good dessert. The onion rings were prepared like I’ve never had before and the calamari was just right. We didn’t have dessert as can be expected since we did eat a lot to begin with, but the drinks were top notch for sure.
Danielle
-
November 28, 2025
Hunter & Thief is one of my favorite places to go! The food, drinks, and overall vibe are one of a kind. Jonathan and Gabby go above and beyond to make each experience unique. For food I highly recommend trying the cornbread, poutine, and burger. Save room and try the chocolate fudge cake for dessert! The cocktails are also amazing and I enjoy the variety and frequent specials. I've also been to various theme nights which have been so fun. Jonathan and Gabby take so much time and effort to make the theme nights immersive so that all guests can enjoy. If you are looking for a place with great food, top-notch drinks, and a vibe that just works, you have to try Hunter & Thief!
Mia Vollaro
-
November 28, 2025
We have been to Hunter and Thief several times now. It is a fun, friendly, and Accommodating establishment. The hosts and owners John and Gabby couldn’t be more welcoming , going out of their way to make sure your visit is the best they can give you. The food is delicious and the drinks are awesome. It is a must if you want a great dining experience. They offer trivia nights and are big supporters of the community - never saying no to helping out those in need. Go see for yourself. You won’t be disappointed !
Our Address
21 W Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, USA
Claim Listing: Hunter & Thief
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Hunter and Thief is truly a home away from home. From elevated comfort food to the welcoming, attentive staff, it’s the perfect spot whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a night of catching up with friends. The modern cocktail bar showcases an impressive lineup of drinks, and owner Jonathan consistently goes above and beyond to deliver twists on classics. And the food? It never disappoints. I’ve sampled nearly everything on their seasonally rotating menu and have been impressed time and time again. Standout favorites include the signature burger, the chopped cheese, the poutine, ricotta toast, and the calamari. As someone who has worked in the service industry, I can truthfully say this place is unlike any other and it will continue to have my business.
Been hosting my reading parties at Hunter & Thief since the summer. Amazing drinks & food! The staff is the best and always very welcoming. TRY THEIR CORNBREAD! I’m obsessed. :)
We went into this place the other day during the Lindenhurst Spring Fest and have to say that the atmosphere, food, and service was absolutely amazing. Although I didn’t get pictures of the food I assure you it was all delicious and well presented. The burger was seasoned perfectly and the chopped cheese sandwich was amazing. The corn bread was so good it would have even made for a good dessert. The onion rings were prepared like I’ve never had before and the calamari was just right. We didn’t have dessert as can be expected since we did eat a lot to begin with, but the drinks were top notch for sure.
Hunter & Thief is one of my favorite places to go! The food, drinks, and overall vibe are one of a kind. Jonathan and Gabby go above and beyond to make each experience unique. For food I highly recommend trying the cornbread, poutine, and burger. Save room and try the chocolate fudge cake for dessert! The cocktails are also amazing and I enjoy the variety and frequent specials. I've also been to various theme nights which have been so fun. Jonathan and Gabby take so much time and effort to make the theme nights immersive so that all guests can enjoy. If you are looking for a place with great food, top-notch drinks, and a vibe that just works, you have to try Hunter & Thief!
We have been to Hunter and Thief several times now. It is a fun, friendly, and Accommodating establishment. The hosts and owners John and Gabby couldn’t be more welcoming , going out of their way to make sure your visit is the best they can give you. The food is delicious and the drinks are awesome. It is a must if you want a great dining experience. They offer trivia nights and are big supporters of the community - never saying no to helping out those in need. Go see for yourself. You won’t be disappointed !