Hunter & Thief

21 W Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, USA

About Hunter & Thief

5 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Tom Garcia
    March 03, 2024

    Came here on a Tuesday night with a party of five and had nothing but pleasant surprises from the time we got there. Starting with the atmosphere, very cute place, on the smaller side, but I like it that way. Lighting, music level, and music choice were all on point, if you wanted to talk to friends, you could very easily do so and plenty well lit so you can see each other. They also have a cute little photo booth in case that tickles your fancy. Drink menu is pretty diverse, especially if you love an Old Fashioned as much as I do, they have a bunch of different options, I went for the Canadian which was very tasty. Food was great too, for apps we tried the ricotta toast, French fries, humus, corn bread and roasted carrots, all were good but I think the corn bread stole the show for me. It comes with a jalapeño butter to embrace the savory side of more southern style cornbread. For the main course I had the chopped cheese, and any bodega owner I think would be proud to have this sandwich, tasty and the perfect portion. Not to mention prices for everything seemed totally reasonable. One of the biggest appeals though, staff was very friendly and kind and never made us feel rushed. Parking is pretty easy, there is a municipal lot just down the block that has plenty of spaces, along with street parking. Would absolutely love to come back here and just get the chance to hangout more.

    Jeanna Damm
    January 28, 2024

    Had girls night here, and we all loved the place. The floating candles and dark walls give it a cool moody vibe. They also had a photobooth which is fun. The bar is pretty long for a small space. We were drawn here for the craft cocktails and those were great too. We started with the ricotta toast which had a little kick to it but very good. I had the arugula salad special and added the grilled chicken - and it was amazing! My friends had the fried chicken sandwich and the fish & chips. I hope they expand the menu in the future because the options were limited if you're coming to eat. The only thing that was disappointing was that they were out of a few items - like some food and they were out of the wine that we wanted to have. But overall we all said that it was a really nice spot, and we'll be back with our partners for date night!

    L O
    February 01, 2024

    What a hidden gem! Absolutely loooved the super relaxed vibe and openness of the place. Jonathan, has such a charming and welcoming personality and gave us ample adv and space and time to just enjoy the place, the decor, the music, and the outstanding food. We had the kale caesar salad, the hummus and fish and chips. All just absolutely exquisite! Only suggestion to replace is the bread w the hummus. The bread was too dry and crumbled too easy to use with the amazing hummus. I would probably serve it with either celery sticks OR pita OR potato chips. Will definitely go back soon !

    Guy Cerino
    September 06, 2023

    The new standard for cocktail bars on Long Island. Hunter and Thief boasts a well curated, seasonal, and evolving cocktail and food menu. Do NOT sleep on the food selection - everything from the ricotta toast, burger, house cut fries and chips, sour cream and onion dip, and kale caesar were amazing. The cocktails are some of the best available on Long Island & the beer list is currently exclusively Cantina Cantina(!). The staff is extremely knowledgable and friendly and make every trip to H&T even more memorable than the last. Every detail of the space was well planned out and fun (check out the take one/leave one nook by the bathrooms!). Lindenhurst is lucky to have this place, and I look forward to tasting through the evolving menu. Cheers!

    Clara Rossilli
    March 15, 2024

    I was so excited to try this place. When I walked in, I was pleasantly surprised; I loved the decor. There were 2 people at the bar and no one at the tables. We were the first ones. 15 minutes later, another table of 4, we were only 2. The service was horrible. We both ordered the fish special, and it was tasteless. I received a tarter sauce, but my friend didn't. We waited and waited she never came back to ask us if we needed anything. We had to get up and ask for it. I was very disappointed 😞

    Hunter & Thief

    Our Address

    21 W Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, USA

    Join the ONLY Babylon Town Website for All of Us!

    Would you like to add your Business or Organization to our site? It’s FREE!  Click the button to get started now >>