I ordered a chicken burrito and steak quesadilla, total was $15. For that money it's hard to complain but the food was very disappointing and I didn't finish the burrito.
Steak Quesadilla: When they gave me the bag i had to double check that they gave me the quesadilla because it was pretty small. Id rather pay another $3-4 for a regular sized one. The steak was rubbery but salty so it was fine.
Chicken Burrito: First, when i opened it see the picture, they almost wrapped an open burrito. The chicken was hard and rubbery, like the steak but even the steak wasn't as hard as the pieces of chicken, it was almost like eating beef jerky. The guacamole was in one glob in one part of the burrito.
Maybe their tacos or sides are better but I don't think I'll be going back to find out.
I'm surprised, maybe there was a mistake or something but for the reviews this restaurant has I expected better.
The location is pretty nice, its on the corner of a local road in West Babylon which is a bit away from the chaos of the Deer Park/North Babylon/Wyandanch area.
Ronnie Cra
-
November 22, 2025
Island Grill food is tasty however if you order from here and don’t mind Being ripped off money go right ahead. I am done with this place. The prices are expensive for what you actually get Every time I went there they would charge me a higher price than what it should be…..it never added up. They were always ripping you off money whether it be $.50 or a dollar. I am never returning again. I am tired of being ripped off from them. When you ask for salsa or sour cream, it’s barely a half a teaspoon in the little Plastic container. I ordered a combination platter and it was 95% rice. So I paid $10 for a bowl of rice With practically nothing else in it. So like I said, the flavor is good but you don’t get what you’re paying for…. if it’s worth it for you go…it’s not worth it for me
Santino Pug (The King)
-
January 10, 2025
I have been coming here for as long as I can remember…. Place has been here since I’m a kid. Nice people. Steak quesadilla is my favorite. Needs to add a couple dipping sauces that would help
Lu J
-
April 14, 2025
The chicken is bad. you get overcharged for everything theyre cheap with ( salsa portion sizes, etc). they won't include anything in your takeout order unless you ask (napkins, etc) along with getting poor service.
the first cup had Less than the 2nd cup shown in the photo. smh. we are left to use our own hot sauce to eat this food from this place just after 4 bites
Zach C
-
April 18, 2022
This place has probably been around longer than I've lived in Babylon. I remember going here when I was in highschool over a decade ago. Staff is super nice and are still very save and cautious with covid procedures.
I got bourbon chicken chimichangas and they were amazing like every other time I've gotten them. Huge portion and very cheap and filling. I love this place so much. My only wish was that they were available on delivery services because I would order way more often.
Our Address
926 Little E Neck Rd, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA
Claim Listing: Island Grill
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I ordered a chicken burrito and steak quesadilla, total was $15. For that money it's hard to complain but the food was very disappointing and I didn't finish the burrito. Steak Quesadilla: When they gave me the bag i had to double check that they gave me the quesadilla because it was pretty small. Id rather pay another $3-4 for a regular sized one. The steak was rubbery but salty so it was fine. Chicken Burrito: First, when i opened it see the picture, they almost wrapped an open burrito. The chicken was hard and rubbery, like the steak but even the steak wasn't as hard as the pieces of chicken, it was almost like eating beef jerky. The guacamole was in one glob in one part of the burrito. Maybe their tacos or sides are better but I don't think I'll be going back to find out. I'm surprised, maybe there was a mistake or something but for the reviews this restaurant has I expected better. The location is pretty nice, its on the corner of a local road in West Babylon which is a bit away from the chaos of the Deer Park/North Babylon/Wyandanch area.
Island Grill food is tasty however if you order from here and don’t mind Being ripped off money go right ahead. I am done with this place. The prices are expensive for what you actually get Every time I went there they would charge me a higher price than what it should be…..it never added up. They were always ripping you off money whether it be $.50 or a dollar. I am never returning again. I am tired of being ripped off from them. When you ask for salsa or sour cream, it’s barely a half a teaspoon in the little Plastic container. I ordered a combination platter and it was 95% rice. So I paid $10 for a bowl of rice With practically nothing else in it. So like I said, the flavor is good but you don’t get what you’re paying for…. if it’s worth it for you go…it’s not worth it for me
I have been coming here for as long as I can remember…. Place has been here since I’m a kid. Nice people. Steak quesadilla is my favorite. Needs to add a couple dipping sauces that would help
The chicken is bad. you get overcharged for everything theyre cheap with ( salsa portion sizes, etc). they won't include anything in your takeout order unless you ask (napkins, etc) along with getting poor service. the first cup had Less than the 2nd cup shown in the photo. smh. we are left to use our own hot sauce to eat this food from this place just after 4 bites
This place has probably been around longer than I've lived in Babylon. I remember going here when I was in highschool over a decade ago. Staff is super nice and are still very save and cautious with covid procedures. I got bourbon chicken chimichangas and they were amazing like every other time I've gotten them. Huge portion and very cheap and filling. I love this place so much. My only wish was that they were available on delivery services because I would order way more often.