The variety of pizza they have is so unique! I wish I was local and could try them all but I had to choose one so I picked the garlic knot slice, which was memorably good. The side Caesar salad was huge and delicious! The croutons were well seasoned, and I’d place the dressing among the best. Also the guys who run the place are nice and the vibe was good. I’d definitely recommend!!
Brian Green
-
May 21, 2025
stumbled upon Mangia’s near Islip, NY, and it turned out to be an absolute gem! The meatballs were some of the best I’ve ever had—juicy, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned. I also tried a zeppole for the first time, and even without the powdered sugar (since I’m not a fan), it was fantastic—light, airy, and delicious. The grandma pizza was another delightful surprise, with a crispy crust and rich, savory sauce. Highly recommend this cozy spot if you’re in the area!
Ann O'Malley
-
September 30, 2024
We got an overstuffed veggie pizza, and a gluten free crust personal pizza (with veggies added). Definitely order the sesame seed crust on the over stuffed pizza. It is SO worth the extra $1.65!! You will be glad you did. (Trust me)....
Kirsten
-
February 16, 2025
The best pizza, garlic knots & sliders ever! I’ve been going to Mangia for decades. Not only is the food top tier but the people are too! Thanks for all you do, John!
Jesse S
-
November 02, 2021
Food is always great here, I'm not even sure this is the restaurants fault since i ordered through slice, but considering this was like $40 that's pretty disappointing. The food is cold too, cheese came completely off the slice just trying to take it. Probably won't order delivery again. Stick to takeout. Again, I don't know if this is even the restaurants fault so.
Our Address
785 Deer Pk Ave Ste C, North Babylon, NY 11703, USA
Claim Listing: Mangia Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
The variety of pizza they have is so unique! I wish I was local and could try them all but I had to choose one so I picked the garlic knot slice, which was memorably good. The side Caesar salad was huge and delicious! The croutons were well seasoned, and I’d place the dressing among the best. Also the guys who run the place are nice and the vibe was good. I’d definitely recommend!!
stumbled upon Mangia’s near Islip, NY, and it turned out to be an absolute gem! The meatballs were some of the best I’ve ever had—juicy, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned. I also tried a zeppole for the first time, and even without the powdered sugar (since I’m not a fan), it was fantastic—light, airy, and delicious. The grandma pizza was another delightful surprise, with a crispy crust and rich, savory sauce. Highly recommend this cozy spot if you’re in the area!
We got an overstuffed veggie pizza, and a gluten free crust personal pizza (with veggies added). Definitely order the sesame seed crust on the over stuffed pizza. It is SO worth the extra $1.65!! You will be glad you did. (Trust me)....
The best pizza, garlic knots & sliders ever! I’ve been going to Mangia for decades. Not only is the food top tier but the people are too! Thanks for all you do, John!
Food is always great here, I'm not even sure this is the restaurants fault since i ordered through slice, but considering this was like $40 that's pretty disappointing. The food is cold too, cheese came completely off the slice just trying to take it. Probably won't order delivery again. Stick to takeout. Again, I don't know if this is even the restaurants fault so.