We went for their Wednesday night chicken special and were born away. We have been to this restaurant before but tonight's experience was on another level. Our server, Marcy, was incredible and so sweet not only to us but every table she visited. She gave a great recommendation to make homemade croutons using our leftover garlic knots. The food is always amazing at Mulberry Street and we can't wait to go back again!
Rebecka Verzeni-Placa
-
July 27, 2025
What a great spot! I love coming in here to grab some pizza and sit outside with my pup! The service is always with a smile and Abe has made the experience very enjoyable. Definitely recommend the vodka slice!!!
Coach Jaye
-
September 15, 2025
we go for either pasta tonight on Monday or chicken Parm night on Wednesday and in between that we sit at the bar for happy hour. If I had one suggestion, I would make happy hours from 4 to 6 instead of 2 to 5. Servers are always friendly and happy food is always delicious. The owners are always here and if there’s any problems they always sell them.
Matthew Huttle
-
June 17, 2025
I came back to the Island to visit family and we went here. I’ve been living out of state for the last three years so I hadn’t had truly authentic Italian food in ages and this was just what I needed for my body and soul. The gluten free penne was so good and tender it didn’t even taste gluten free. I would have asked to make sure there wasn’t a mixup but our waiter, Joe, was so on top of things I knew I didn’t have to. He said it was his first night but I almost didn’t believe him. He was warm, pleasant, thoughtful, charming, and carried himself like a damn pro!
Oh, and then the manager hands us a bottle of Merlot on the way out, just to thank us for being there!
This is the real Italian warmth, hospitality, food, and service you can only find in NY!
We’re definitely coming back, and you’d be wise to bring your crew there, too!
Frances Villa
-
September 23, 2025
9/12/25 I ordered on phone 7 different types of chicken meals & pasta dishes with some special request & plus sides for dinner. Everyone loved their choices. The dinners were very generous portions. From the cook to the delivery man, my food was delivered on time & came hot.(I got too old to cook different dishes for my adult kids when they come to visit ) The manager sent a bottle of wine on the house (so thoughtful). I haven't been the restaurant for 5yrs or more so I don't know about the atmosphere. But I'm sure it will be nice from what i hear But I only tried it again because I read it the new owners are now same as mamas in Copiague. .I tell you that you will not be disappointed. And prepared the way you like it The food is freshly made you can tell. I plan on being a customer again & so are my family members & I told my friends
Our Address
30 E Main St, Babylon, NY 11702, USA
Claim Listing: Mulberry Street Babylon
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
We went for their Wednesday night chicken special and were born away. We have been to this restaurant before but tonight's experience was on another level. Our server, Marcy, was incredible and so sweet not only to us but every table she visited. She gave a great recommendation to make homemade croutons using our leftover garlic knots. The food is always amazing at Mulberry Street and we can't wait to go back again!
What a great spot! I love coming in here to grab some pizza and sit outside with my pup! The service is always with a smile and Abe has made the experience very enjoyable. Definitely recommend the vodka slice!!!
we go for either pasta tonight on Monday or chicken Parm night on Wednesday and in between that we sit at the bar for happy hour. If I had one suggestion, I would make happy hours from 4 to 6 instead of 2 to 5. Servers are always friendly and happy food is always delicious. The owners are always here and if there’s any problems they always sell them.
I came back to the Island to visit family and we went here. I’ve been living out of state for the last three years so I hadn’t had truly authentic Italian food in ages and this was just what I needed for my body and soul. The gluten free penne was so good and tender it didn’t even taste gluten free. I would have asked to make sure there wasn’t a mixup but our waiter, Joe, was so on top of things I knew I didn’t have to. He said it was his first night but I almost didn’t believe him. He was warm, pleasant, thoughtful, charming, and carried himself like a damn pro! Oh, and then the manager hands us a bottle of Merlot on the way out, just to thank us for being there! This is the real Italian warmth, hospitality, food, and service you can only find in NY! We’re definitely coming back, and you’d be wise to bring your crew there, too!
9/12/25 I ordered on phone 7 different types of chicken meals & pasta dishes with some special request & plus sides for dinner. Everyone loved their choices. The dinners were very generous portions. From the cook to the delivery man, my food was delivered on time & came hot.(I got too old to cook different dishes for my adult kids when they come to visit ) The manager sent a bottle of wine on the house (so thoughtful). I haven't been the restaurant for 5yrs or more so I don't know about the atmosphere. But I'm sure it will be nice from what i hear But I only tried it again because I read it the new owners are now same as mamas in Copiague. .I tell you that you will not be disappointed. And prepared the way you like it The food is freshly made you can tell. I plan on being a customer again & so are my family members & I told my friends