We had a fantastic experience at Mulberry Street, a lovely Italian restaurant in Babylon Village. We were greeted warmly by the manager as soon as we walked in, which set the tone for a great night. Our server, Marcy, was friendly, attentive, and let us know that Wednesdays are their special chicken day which included a salad, garlic knots, cheesecake, and coffee/tea. We ordered the Chicken Marsala and Chicken Da Vinci—both were delicious, and the portions were huge! I also had the Fig Cosmo, which was a standout. Everything was excellent. We’ll definitely be back!
Christian Magnuson
-
March 30, 2025
We stopped in last minute and were welcomed and seated right away. The appetizers and salads came out promptly. The main course came out hot and delicious. We would be returning. Our waitress Angela was incredibly accommodating!
Lina DeFalco
-
June 28, 2025
We had a great experience at Mulberry Street! The food was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. The pasta was cooked perfectly—just the right texture—and the salad was crisp and refreshing, topped with delicious eggplant that added a nice touch. The pizza was very good, with just the right balance of toppings and a crust that was spot on.
Ab, the owner, was so personable and welcoming—he truly made us feel right at home.
Mulberry Street is definitely a go-to spot for dinner. If you haven’t been yet, check them out—you won’t be disappointed!
Matthew Huttle
-
June 17, 2025
I came back to the Island to visit family and we went here. I’ve been living out of state for the last three years so I hadn’t had truly authentic Italian food in ages and this was just what I needed for my body and soul. The gluten free penne was so good and tender it didn’t even taste gluten free. I would have asked to make sure there wasn’t a mixup but our waiter, Joe, was so on top of things I knew I didn’t have to. He said it was his first night but I almost didn’t believe him. He was warm, pleasant, thoughtful, charming, and carried himself like a damn pro!
Oh, and then the manager hands us a bottle of Merlot on the way out, just to thank us for being there!
This is the real Italian warmth, hospitality, food, and service you can only find in NY!
We’re definitely coming back, and you’d be wise to bring your crew there, too!
cali byrnes
-
June 20, 2025
Mulberry is hands-down one of the best pizza spots around, the food is amazing! But what really makes it special is the staff. They’re friendly, genuine, and brings great vibes to the whole place. You always feel welcome, and the pizza never misses. I have also dined in and it was the perfect meal and once again the staff was great! 10/10, highly recommend!
Our Address
30 E Main St, Babylon, NY 11702, USA
Claim Listing: Mulberry Street Babylon
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
We had a fantastic experience at Mulberry Street, a lovely Italian restaurant in Babylon Village. We were greeted warmly by the manager as soon as we walked in, which set the tone for a great night. Our server, Marcy, was friendly, attentive, and let us know that Wednesdays are their special chicken day which included a salad, garlic knots, cheesecake, and coffee/tea. We ordered the Chicken Marsala and Chicken Da Vinci—both were delicious, and the portions were huge! I also had the Fig Cosmo, which was a standout. Everything was excellent. We’ll definitely be back!
We stopped in last minute and were welcomed and seated right away. The appetizers and salads came out promptly. The main course came out hot and delicious. We would be returning. Our waitress Angela was incredibly accommodating!
We had a great experience at Mulberry Street! The food was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. The pasta was cooked perfectly—just the right texture—and the salad was crisp and refreshing, topped with delicious eggplant that added a nice touch. The pizza was very good, with just the right balance of toppings and a crust that was spot on. Ab, the owner, was so personable and welcoming—he truly made us feel right at home. Mulberry Street is definitely a go-to spot for dinner. If you haven’t been yet, check them out—you won’t be disappointed!
I came back to the Island to visit family and we went here. I’ve been living out of state for the last three years so I hadn’t had truly authentic Italian food in ages and this was just what I needed for my body and soul. The gluten free penne was so good and tender it didn’t even taste gluten free. I would have asked to make sure there wasn’t a mixup but our waiter, Joe, was so on top of things I knew I didn’t have to. He said it was his first night but I almost didn’t believe him. He was warm, pleasant, thoughtful, charming, and carried himself like a damn pro! Oh, and then the manager hands us a bottle of Merlot on the way out, just to thank us for being there! This is the real Italian warmth, hospitality, food, and service you can only find in NY! We’re definitely coming back, and you’d be wise to bring your crew there, too!
Mulberry is hands-down one of the best pizza spots around, the food is amazing! But what really makes it special is the staff. They’re friendly, genuine, and brings great vibes to the whole place. You always feel welcome, and the pizza never misses. I have also dined in and it was the perfect meal and once again the staff was great! 10/10, highly recommend!