On all measures that matter in a restaurant, this place was truly excellent ! Ambiance with nice quiet music, high quality food, excellent service, and very fair prices. I've lived on Long Island all my life and have tried many restaurants. Mulberry Street is at the very top of the list. We will come back repeatedly. Highly recommend!
Jason Nabel
-
September 19, 2023
Met a friend at Mulberry street located in an unassuming shopping center off the main strip. We ordered a delicious beet salad and some meat eggroll. Both were delicious and a perfect way to start a meal along with the delicious garlic knots they put on the table. We also ordered a delicious Sicilian ribbon pasta layer with eggplant peas and mozzarella. The sauce was so rich and delicious you didn’t miss it was all veggie and no meat. After that unexpectedly heavy dish I’m glad I ordered seabass. It was cooked perfectly served with deckhouse brocolli rabe in a spicy broth. Excellent dish. For dessert Our wonderful server highly recommended the carrot cake and the lobster claw they recently added to the menu. The lobster claw patty was the best I’ve had.
Thoroughly enjoyed my visit and meal and highly recommend to pop in for a slice or a nice family meal.
Timothy Erwig
-
July 20, 2023
Sadly, my family won't be doing business with this restaurant again. Ordered a pizza and it came burnt. Mistakes happen so we call and the said they would send another pie but to give the driver the original one. Weird but okay. We waited an hour and called again because nothing was delivered. At this point we just asked for a refund. The woman who answered was very rude and said the order was already in and we should wait another 10 minutes. So from the original order until the second pie arrived was over 2 hours. The best part..... The second pie was burnt as well. Pictures of both pies are included. These people just don't care what goes out the door.
Laura Sciortino
-
July 18, 2024
We were having a special Almafi coast bridal shower on Sunday July 14th under tents in my yard. We had 50 people and we specifically served itslian apps and food. We ordered a half tray of fried calamari which was about 100.00 dollars. My son went to pick it up at 1200 which was the specified time and he waited a half hour. Which the bridal shower was for his fiancé on top of it. We set it out as soon as he arrived….. no one ate it I still have the whole tray. It was all rubbery chewy and filled with all breadcrumbs. Quite a few people told me this. I was upset since it was part of the chosen apps. I called to speak to the owner Nicole explained what happened I told her I have the whole tray would you like it back since no one can eat it.
She declined and said the best she could do was offer me a 25 dollar certificate which is a slap in the face. I spent close to 100 dollars and still have the whole tray which is being dumped. She could care less about the times I told her we were there through the YEARS for many family functions that’s why I chose the place. Because she didn’t credit me back I will no longer ever go to this restersunt in babylon ny ever again. Disgraceful. I am not even using the gift certificate. I wouldn’t give that place any more of my hard earned money!
Donna Johnson-Fiorello
-
June 10, 2024
I visited your restaurant on Saturday - June 8, 2024with 18 people. YES, 18 people. I work with a special needs organization and visited the restaurant after A Bronx Tale on Saturday afternoon. We have seen many plays at the Argyle and passed your restaurant countless times. My guys have always asked to eat there and I have put it off figuring I had NO CHANCE at getting reservation and/or accommodating all of us at once and/or having it be a 5 hour dining experience.
I WAS WRONG! SO, SO, SO WRONG!!!
I took a chance last week and called to make a reservation. Marcy spoke with me. SO, SO, SOOOO nice. Maura had called during the week to confirm that I still had 18 coming and I said “yes, is that still ok?” I got an ABSOLUTELY!!
The play ended at 4:45pm and it was a 5 minute walk with all my guys there. I went in and Maura was there and said you guys can come on in - I kinda just stood there. I was like “really?” Maura said, yes! Everyone was seated right away! Marcy was our server! My guys had their food ordered and were done eating by 6pm and I just couldn’t believe it! They LOVED, and when I say LOVED - LOVED your restaurant and can NOT wait to come back!
I cannot commend you enough on Maura and Marcy! INCREDIBLE is an understatement and AMAZINGLY PHENOMENAL doesn’t do them justice!
In the 15 years I have worked with my guys - THIS, HANDS DOWN was by far the BEST dining experience EVER!!!
Grateful beyond words!!!
Thank you, thank you, thank you!
Donna
Celebrate #AdministrativeProfessionalsWeek with beautiful floral arrangements from Gifts From the Heart Florist 🌸💼 Show your appreciation for their hard work and dedication! 💐✨ Shop now: GiftsFromtheHeartFlorist.com #GiftsFromTheHeartFlorist 🌺🌿
On all measures that matter in a restaurant, this place was truly excellent ! Ambiance with nice quiet music, high quality food, excellent service, and very fair prices. I've lived on Long Island all my life and have tried many restaurants. Mulberry Street is at the very top of the list. We will come back repeatedly. Highly recommend!
Met a friend at Mulberry street located in an unassuming shopping center off the main strip. We ordered a delicious beet salad and some meat eggroll. Both were delicious and a perfect way to start a meal along with the delicious garlic knots they put on the table. We also ordered a delicious Sicilian ribbon pasta layer with eggplant peas and mozzarella. The sauce was so rich and delicious you didn’t miss it was all veggie and no meat. After that unexpectedly heavy dish I’m glad I ordered seabass. It was cooked perfectly served with deckhouse brocolli rabe in a spicy broth. Excellent dish. For dessert Our wonderful server highly recommended the carrot cake and the lobster claw they recently added to the menu. The lobster claw patty was the best I’ve had. Thoroughly enjoyed my visit and meal and highly recommend to pop in for a slice or a nice family meal.
Sadly, my family won't be doing business with this restaurant again. Ordered a pizza and it came burnt. Mistakes happen so we call and the said they would send another pie but to give the driver the original one. Weird but okay. We waited an hour and called again because nothing was delivered. At this point we just asked for a refund. The woman who answered was very rude and said the order was already in and we should wait another 10 minutes. So from the original order until the second pie arrived was over 2 hours. The best part..... The second pie was burnt as well. Pictures of both pies are included. These people just don't care what goes out the door.
We were having a special Almafi coast bridal shower on Sunday July 14th under tents in my yard. We had 50 people and we specifically served itslian apps and food. We ordered a half tray of fried calamari which was about 100.00 dollars. My son went to pick it up at 1200 which was the specified time and he waited a half hour. Which the bridal shower was for his fiancé on top of it. We set it out as soon as he arrived….. no one ate it I still have the whole tray. It was all rubbery chewy and filled with all breadcrumbs. Quite a few people told me this. I was upset since it was part of the chosen apps. I called to speak to the owner Nicole explained what happened I told her I have the whole tray would you like it back since no one can eat it. She declined and said the best she could do was offer me a 25 dollar certificate which is a slap in the face. I spent close to 100 dollars and still have the whole tray which is being dumped. She could care less about the times I told her we were there through the YEARS for many family functions that’s why I chose the place. Because she didn’t credit me back I will no longer ever go to this restersunt in babylon ny ever again. Disgraceful. I am not even using the gift certificate. I wouldn’t give that place any more of my hard earned money!
I visited your restaurant on Saturday - June 8, 2024with 18 people. YES, 18 people. I work with a special needs organization and visited the restaurant after A Bronx Tale on Saturday afternoon. We have seen many plays at the Argyle and passed your restaurant countless times. My guys have always asked to eat there and I have put it off figuring I had NO CHANCE at getting reservation and/or accommodating all of us at once and/or having it be a 5 hour dining experience. I WAS WRONG! SO, SO, SO WRONG!!! I took a chance last week and called to make a reservation. Marcy spoke with me. SO, SO, SOOOO nice. Maura had called during the week to confirm that I still had 18 coming and I said “yes, is that still ok?” I got an ABSOLUTELY!! The play ended at 4:45pm and it was a 5 minute walk with all my guys there. I went in and Maura was there and said you guys can come on in - I kinda just stood there. I was like “really?” Maura said, yes! Everyone was seated right away! Marcy was our server! My guys had their food ordered and were done eating by 6pm and I just couldn’t believe it! They LOVED, and when I say LOVED - LOVED your restaurant and can NOT wait to come back! I cannot commend you enough on Maura and Marcy! INCREDIBLE is an understatement and AMAZINGLY PHENOMENAL doesn’t do them justice! In the 15 years I have worked with my guys - THIS, HANDS DOWN was by far the BEST dining experience EVER!!! Grateful beyond words!!! Thank you, thank you, thank you! Donna