My husband and I come to Nonna Bella’s for lunch if we decide on pizza even though there’s a pizzeria much closer to our home. We’ve never been disappointed with the individual slices and the service is always good. Last week we had some friends over with their daughter and we decided to order some pies for delivery. We ordered a Cesar salad, a plain and a meat lovers pie. The plain pie was good as usual, but meat lovers pie was absolutely delicious. The crust was slightly charred and the pepperoni, meatball and sausage were just perfect. The pie disappeared so quick, I wish I ordered a second one. I’ll have to try their dinners because if it’s even half as good as their pizza, I won’t be disappointed.
Michael Ragan
-
October 24, 2024
Pizza is very good but some of their gourmet pizzas are the best. Many are even available by the slice.
But what really surprised me when I started ordering dinners there. Everything I've tried from there is excellent! And the first time I tried their Caesar salad I was absolutely amazed - it's just as good as some of my favorite restaurants.
PS - Try their Tuesday pasta special. Same full size portions and you get a salad and choice of dessert. Great inflation buster deal - only about $16 bucks . . . Try it!
Christine Rescigno
-
March 10, 2024
I asked for a hot honey pie which is listed as a grandma on their site. I asked if half the pie could be just cheese because I had some family that likes plain but I wasn’t having a ton of people so I had hoped it would workout. It seemed what I was asking for was clear, however, the girl was clearly new on the phone and new in general because she had to keep asking someone what I was asking her. But instead of that person getting on the phone to confirm what I was asking for they just kept talking thru her. Anyway the pizza comes that clearly is not hot honey it was vodka sauce. And instead of the flaky delicious grandma crust I got uncooked doughy cold Sicilian. And I asked for 4 regular slices I thought they could atleast give me half of a new pie but instead I got an old sitting on the counter all day slices. Also the weirdest tasting Cesar dressing ever and idk what Cesar comes without romaine lettuce but this was shredded like you would throw it on a cold cut sandwich. Idk I guess for 64 dollars 72 after tip I just was disappointed. I mean even the mozzerella sticks were like they cooked it before the pizza.
Christian C
-
August 12, 2024
My girlfriend and I decided to give this place a try. The pizza is very good, crispy crust and great prices. The only thing that turned me off was seeing the girl handling my food put my slices in then touch her dirty phone and her hair then handle my food again. However I would give this place another try
Tammy S
-
November 30, 2024
I order delivery from them often. Always on time and their food is great!! My favorites are their heroes and gourmet personal pizzas!
Our Address
765 Deer Pk Ave, North Babylon, NY 11703, USA
Claim Listing: Nonna Bella’s
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
My husband and I come to Nonna Bella’s for lunch if we decide on pizza even though there’s a pizzeria much closer to our home. We’ve never been disappointed with the individual slices and the service is always good. Last week we had some friends over with their daughter and we decided to order some pies for delivery. We ordered a Cesar salad, a plain and a meat lovers pie. The plain pie was good as usual, but meat lovers pie was absolutely delicious. The crust was slightly charred and the pepperoni, meatball and sausage were just perfect. The pie disappeared so quick, I wish I ordered a second one. I’ll have to try their dinners because if it’s even half as good as their pizza, I won’t be disappointed.
Pizza is very good but some of their gourmet pizzas are the best. Many are even available by the slice. But what really surprised me when I started ordering dinners there. Everything I've tried from there is excellent! And the first time I tried their Caesar salad I was absolutely amazed - it's just as good as some of my favorite restaurants. PS - Try their Tuesday pasta special. Same full size portions and you get a salad and choice of dessert. Great inflation buster deal - only about $16 bucks . . . Try it!
I asked for a hot honey pie which is listed as a grandma on their site. I asked if half the pie could be just cheese because I had some family that likes plain but I wasn’t having a ton of people so I had hoped it would workout. It seemed what I was asking for was clear, however, the girl was clearly new on the phone and new in general because she had to keep asking someone what I was asking her. But instead of that person getting on the phone to confirm what I was asking for they just kept talking thru her. Anyway the pizza comes that clearly is not hot honey it was vodka sauce. And instead of the flaky delicious grandma crust I got uncooked doughy cold Sicilian. And I asked for 4 regular slices I thought they could atleast give me half of a new pie but instead I got an old sitting on the counter all day slices. Also the weirdest tasting Cesar dressing ever and idk what Cesar comes without romaine lettuce but this was shredded like you would throw it on a cold cut sandwich. Idk I guess for 64 dollars 72 after tip I just was disappointed. I mean even the mozzerella sticks were like they cooked it before the pizza.
My girlfriend and I decided to give this place a try. The pizza is very good, crispy crust and great prices. The only thing that turned me off was seeing the girl handling my food put my slices in then touch her dirty phone and her hair then handle my food again. However I would give this place another try
I order delivery from them often. Always on time and their food is great!! My favorites are their heroes and gourmet personal pizzas!