I was disturbed eating pizza after I found a big black long hair in my pizza. I took a bite of the chicken Buffalo slice and there it was. It definitely wasn’t mine or my wife’s. It was so disgusting. In addition, do you see how much oil is one both those pizzas. It was a soup fest. Presentation terrible. I can make a better pizza with my eyes closed and with no hairs in it.
This pizza place is the worst on Long Island I’ve had. It’s laughable how bad it is. It was my mistake ordering pizza here multiple times and bad every time. The reviews look good so you world think but they are not true. The owner who replies with they will improve will not. I have tried pizza here in a 6 year span and it’s the same. This place should be closed down and the staff should be fired. You do not take pride in making pizza.
Jillian Stworzydlak
-
April 19, 2025
One of best Italian meals and overall experience we’ve had in many years. Traveling in from Buffalo for a local event, we wanted the local long running restaurant experience. There seemed like 100 to choose from. We were blown away, our server was amazing, truly some of the best pizza and Italian food in NY. It started with a slice of 5/5 pizza for an appetizer, followed up by chicken Parmesan made perfect with a sauce we wish we could have taken home. The Italian sausage and shrimp scampi were awesome. Everything was 5/5 right down to the zeppole for dessert. Pricing was great for truly home made food , Highly recommended if you want an authentic Sicilian style meal with best service on Long Island!
Tai Vicari
-
August 07, 2024
It's all about the crust and Nunzios NAILED IT! Crispy delicious thin crust so so good. Especially when it's fresh out of the oven. I highly recommend just having a slice and sitting inside. Bring the family. Pizza night out!
And for a real stuff your face treat...the Calzones. Cheesy goodness with a side of sauce.
Walk in and roll out!!!
Lisa Ann
-
March 01, 2025
Pizza was delicious and they have the best zeppoles! Friendly staff and fast service.
Benjamin Yencha
-
March 24, 2025
Good pizza and seems family run so customer service is top notch. My friend loves the zepolis. They were good but eat them outside. Lol very messy. Don't eat in your car.
Our Address
751 NY-109, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA
Claim Listing: Nunzios Pizza Town
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I was disturbed eating pizza after I found a big black long hair in my pizza. I took a bite of the chicken Buffalo slice and there it was. It definitely wasn’t mine or my wife’s. It was so disgusting. In addition, do you see how much oil is one both those pizzas. It was a soup fest. Presentation terrible. I can make a better pizza with my eyes closed and with no hairs in it. This pizza place is the worst on Long Island I’ve had. It’s laughable how bad it is. It was my mistake ordering pizza here multiple times and bad every time. The reviews look good so you world think but they are not true. The owner who replies with they will improve will not. I have tried pizza here in a 6 year span and it’s the same. This place should be closed down and the staff should be fired. You do not take pride in making pizza.
One of best Italian meals and overall experience we’ve had in many years. Traveling in from Buffalo for a local event, we wanted the local long running restaurant experience. There seemed like 100 to choose from. We were blown away, our server was amazing, truly some of the best pizza and Italian food in NY. It started with a slice of 5/5 pizza for an appetizer, followed up by chicken Parmesan made perfect with a sauce we wish we could have taken home. The Italian sausage and shrimp scampi were awesome. Everything was 5/5 right down to the zeppole for dessert. Pricing was great for truly home made food , Highly recommended if you want an authentic Sicilian style meal with best service on Long Island!
It's all about the crust and Nunzios NAILED IT! Crispy delicious thin crust so so good. Especially when it's fresh out of the oven. I highly recommend just having a slice and sitting inside. Bring the family. Pizza night out! And for a real stuff your face treat...the Calzones. Cheesy goodness with a side of sauce. Walk in and roll out!!!
Pizza was delicious and they have the best zeppoles! Friendly staff and fast service.
Good pizza and seems family run so customer service is top notch. My friend loves the zepolis. They were good but eat them outside. Lol very messy. Don't eat in your car.