Olympic Diner

1536 Deer Pk Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729, USA

About Olympic Diner

4.2 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Laura D
    -
    April 06, 2024

    We have visited this diner several times for breakfast and have enjoyed it, however we went today and it wasn't a great experience. Aside from the price increase in the menu, paying for food that you hope to enjoy, and don't is unacceptable. Please if you decide to have breakfast I ask that you please check your potatoes and overall food! Our home fries tasted spoiled(sour, tangy tste), we told the server who did take our plates however only 2-3minutes we get the plate stating they were a fresh batch. She told us it would take some time, but like i said 2-3 minutes we get the plate back with a new fresh batch of potatoes? Very doubtful! Since they were crispy the outer looked fine but you eat in between and spoiled taste. My husband and sister in-law ordered the healthy omelet which has egg whites and boy did that omelet smell! Come on even the omelette has an odor, like rotten egg! After that I had no appetite to even finish my western omelette! We are not ones to make a commotion at the restaurant and because we were with our children we opted to wait to speak to the manager. Unfortunately that wasn't of much help, she insisted the potatoes are just seasoned differently! Like please, spoiled food even with seasonings taste bad period! When you eat here make sure your taste buds are 100% and don't keep quiet like we did or you'll be stuck with the bill. Don't let the appearance fool you!

    Crazy Aaron
    -
    April 06, 2024

    The potatoes were sour and smelled bad, we did not finish them because they tasted old, we asked for new potatoes and they gave us them in less then 3 minutes( how are new potatoes supposed to be ready in 3 minutes? Just be realistic.) The potatoes still tasted sour and old. The eggs also tasted weird, we have been here 3 times and we won’t be coming back, don’t recommend this place and if you do go please try to smell and taste the food to see if it’s good. The kids left there food because they lost their appetite, and we still had to pay for the full meals.

    Rose Mathieu
    -
    July 17, 2023

    I was impressed with this diner. I entered the restaurant and was immediately greeted with a welcoming “hello and welcome”. Service was excellent! The waiter was friendly and nice. He was very attentive. Food was great! Lots of choices from the menu. Overall great experience!

    Renee Cutaia
    -
    December 25, 2022

    We have been coming to this diner for years and my family for years before that. This is one of the best diners in the area and one of the best that I’ve been to in Long Island. Several years back they renovated this location but kept all the old feel/taste. My favorite meal here is breakfast but the lunch & dinner are also good. No matter what meal you go for you will always come away happy and full. The portions are more than generous, always well prepared and the prices are super reasonable. My favorite is the French toast because they use fresh brioche bread which sucks up all the batter and makes such a soft & buttery toast. The home potatoes are also one of our favorites and they can make them extra crispy (crunchy but not burnt) which is so good. We also enjoy the various salads at lunch time, also very big portions but good. Service here is also pretty amazing. Always greeted with a warm smile and hello when we arrive. Usually there is no wait for seats but if there is the wait is usually not very long. Food comes out pretty fast and the waiters are always attending to you which is helpful. Most of the tables are set up for small groups (family of 4-6) but if you need a bigger area they can accommodate. As for the pastries, I’d say there is nothing overly amazing but they do everything well so you won’t be disappointed. One of the family favorites is the cheese cakes and milkshakes. Come support local businesses and come enjoy a hearty meal with your family and friends…highly recommend!

    Tara K
    -
    May 14, 2023

    Mother's Day Dinner, we were quickly seated. Our server was Ray. He was friendly, energetic and impressive with how he memorized our table's order, along with another table!!! And everything was correct. We started with the fried shrimp for an appetizer. The coating was nice, and they were perfectly fried. My husband had the dinner special Teriyaki Trio of steak, chicken and shrimp over rice. It came with a soup or salad, he chose Manhattan Clam Chowder. It was loaded with vegetables and potatoes, not clams and prerty flavorless. He loved the Teriyaki Trio, which was a generous portion. I ordered the Stuffed Shrimp dinner special with cream of turkey soup. The soup, while not very thick, was delicious. I got 4 shrimp over stuffed with crab meat. They were excellent. I chose spinach for my vegetable and it was deliciously sauteed. It was a great dinner and service experience.

    Olympic Diner

    Our Address

    1536 Deer Pk Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729, USA

    Join the ONLY Babylon Town Website for All of Us!

    Would you like to add your Business or Organization to our site? It’s FREE!  Click the button to get started now >>