Peter Pan Diner

999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA

About Peter Pan Diner

4.4 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Fabby momz
    January 12, 2024

    Food was really delicious. Service was great ! Nice inviting atmosphere. Love the birthday celebration style. Overall was a nice place to sit and enjoy my meal .

    February 27, 2024

    Never order the liquor. First, let me say the food is wonderful. The servers are quite kind. But again, DON'T ORDER THE LIQUOR. I asked for an Old Fashioned at first; I saw they had a collection of whiskey, so I figured it wouldn't be that big of an ask. Unfortunately, neither the server nor whoever they had working behind the counter seemed to know very much about making drinks. So instead I just ordered a Jack & Coke. $12.95 for a freaking Jack & Coke. That's insane! They'd make back the bottle in 3 drinks! Jack Daniels is NOT pricey. I've paid less for elevated cocktails in the city. And had they given me a good cocktail, I would've said that was a fair price. But no, they gave me a splash of jack with a heavy dose of soda. That's $8 max, not $12.95. I should've known better than to order it when I didn't see the liquor menu, I guess. Aside from that, the food is some of the best on the Island and the service is phenomenal. Tip 'em well, they deserve it.

    February 18, 2024

    Way better than your average diner. Selection of dishes was almost overwhelming with some non-run-of-the-mill selections. The food was also really good. Each person in my family completely cleaned the plate. We will come back here when in the area

    Mary Burns
    January 02, 2024

    Came here for dinner on New Year’s Day!! What a great staff and great way to ring in the new year. We especially appreciated our waitress, Shari, who warmed our cold hands with warm mugs. She was inviting and friendly and very attentive to our dining needs. Wonderful vibe at Peter Pan Diner!! And food was amazing too…

    Robert RKNY26 (PresRKNY)
    December 05, 2023

    An all time favorite of mine as they transport me back to my childhood with their Chocolate Chip/Peanut butter chip Pancakes which are amazing. Every other dish I’ve gotten here has been just as good. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the prices are reasonable.

    Peter Pan Diner

    Our Address

    999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA

    Join the ONLY Babylon Town Website for All of Us!

    Would you like to add your Business or Organization to our site? It’s FREE!  Click the button to get started now >>