We were in the area and wanted to grab a quick lunch. The place wasn’t too busy, so we were seated right away. Our server was attentive when taking our order, and the food came out pretty quickly.
We ordered a few things, including the fish and chips. Everything was good—except for the fish. While the fish itself was decent, it was covered in an extremely thick batter. The batter overwhelmed the fish, making it not very enjoyable. Ideally, you want the batter to be a thin, crispy layer. I definitely wouldn’t recommend ordering it.
Once we finished our meal, we requested the check. For some reason, our server didn’t bring it after several minutes of waiting. We flagged them down again to ask for it, and they responded, “I didn’t bring the check?” A few more minutes passed, and we were still waiting. We had to flag the server a third time just to get our check. It was pretty frustrating and annoying. Once we finally got the check, we paid our bill and left—and we likely won’t be coming back.
Maria Howard
-
June 04, 2025
I had my daughter and son in law's baby shower there. Room was perfect and the food was plentiful and delicious. The room was separated from the rest of the restaurant which made it very comfortable for the party
Eileen Pfeifer
-
April 09, 2025
I hosted a baby shower and everything from start to finish was great! Working with Melissa was a pleasure. She answered every question promptly and efficiently. The set up was great and staff and service as well. All my guests commented on how delicious the food was and we even got to bring home the leftovers!
Emily P
-
April 16, 2025
My mother had the most gorgeous baby shower brunch for me over the weekend. My guest raved about the food, decor and staff throughout the event. Everyone was so warm and welcoming and very attentive to my guests. 10/10 experience. Thank you PO!
Jaclyn DeFiore
-
June 12, 2025
I recently made a reservation here for a small group luncheon celebrating a colleague's retirement. It was simply perfect! The food was absolutely delicious- everyone loved their meals! The cheesecake was a big hit too! Our server Chelsea was very attentive and friendly. It was a great experience, and I look forward to having more group outings at Post Office Cafe!
Our Address
130 W Main St, Babylon, NY 11702, USA
Claim Listing: Post Office Café
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
We were in the area and wanted to grab a quick lunch. The place wasn’t too busy, so we were seated right away. Our server was attentive when taking our order, and the food came out pretty quickly. We ordered a few things, including the fish and chips. Everything was good—except for the fish. While the fish itself was decent, it was covered in an extremely thick batter. The batter overwhelmed the fish, making it not very enjoyable. Ideally, you want the batter to be a thin, crispy layer. I definitely wouldn’t recommend ordering it. Once we finished our meal, we requested the check. For some reason, our server didn’t bring it after several minutes of waiting. We flagged them down again to ask for it, and they responded, “I didn’t bring the check?” A few more minutes passed, and we were still waiting. We had to flag the server a third time just to get our check. It was pretty frustrating and annoying. Once we finally got the check, we paid our bill and left—and we likely won’t be coming back.
I had my daughter and son in law's baby shower there. Room was perfect and the food was plentiful and delicious. The room was separated from the rest of the restaurant which made it very comfortable for the party
I hosted a baby shower and everything from start to finish was great! Working with Melissa was a pleasure. She answered every question promptly and efficiently. The set up was great and staff and service as well. All my guests commented on how delicious the food was and we even got to bring home the leftovers!
My mother had the most gorgeous baby shower brunch for me over the weekend. My guest raved about the food, decor and staff throughout the event. Everyone was so warm and welcoming and very attentive to my guests. 10/10 experience. Thank you PO!
I recently made a reservation here for a small group luncheon celebrating a colleague's retirement. It was simply perfect! The food was absolutely delicious- everyone loved their meals! The cheesecake was a big hit too! Our server Chelsea was very attentive and friendly. It was a great experience, and I look forward to having more group outings at Post Office Cafe!