In December 2011 and August 2018, this place was Signal 8 Saloon. (Dates from Google Maps photos.) In November 2019 and today (May 2025), this place is Cousin Craig's Sports Bar.
jerry lourenco
-
August 28, 2015
I live close by and was excited about trying this place out. My wife and I went there on a Thursday afternoon and to say we felt uncomfortable is an understatement. The bar was filled with male townie patrons who clearly did not want us there. We sat down at 2 empty seats at the bar after asking the bartender if they were occupied, and not long after some loser comes walking in complaining that he usually sits there??? Beer was warm, place smelled, I ordered a makers mark and at least it was cheap. We will never go back, and you lost great patrons who spend a lot and tip great. Good luck, your 20 customers is all you will ever have with that vibe. We now go up the block to a bar that is great.
Chris R
-
November 12, 2012
I was pleasantly suprised after leaving here. Looked like just a local spot but everyone in there was more then friendly and they had every football game you could want going on TV. The football drink specials were great and the food was very good as well. The pool table was nice to have, was never a pool player but that didn't disuade anyone from playing a game, or allowing me to jump on the table next. Quickly made many new friends and the next time i'm in the area i'll be sure to go back.
Anthony Verderosa
-
April 21, 2024
Great local dive, Trish is the bomb bartender on Saturdays
jo bloggs
-
November 14, 2018
Late at night but met some nice chilled cool.people..girl behind the bar was so friendly too..
Worth a visit
Our Address
80 Montauk Hwy, Amityville, NY 11701, USA
Claim Listing: Signal 8 Saloon
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
In December 2011 and August 2018, this place was Signal 8 Saloon. (Dates from Google Maps photos.) In November 2019 and today (May 2025), this place is Cousin Craig's Sports Bar.
I live close by and was excited about trying this place out. My wife and I went there on a Thursday afternoon and to say we felt uncomfortable is an understatement. The bar was filled with male townie patrons who clearly did not want us there. We sat down at 2 empty seats at the bar after asking the bartender if they were occupied, and not long after some loser comes walking in complaining that he usually sits there??? Beer was warm, place smelled, I ordered a makers mark and at least it was cheap. We will never go back, and you lost great patrons who spend a lot and tip great. Good luck, your 20 customers is all you will ever have with that vibe. We now go up the block to a bar that is great.
I was pleasantly suprised after leaving here. Looked like just a local spot but everyone in there was more then friendly and they had every football game you could want going on TV. The football drink specials were great and the food was very good as well. The pool table was nice to have, was never a pool player but that didn't disuade anyone from playing a game, or allowing me to jump on the table next. Quickly made many new friends and the next time i'm in the area i'll be sure to go back.
Great local dive, Trish is the bomb bartender on Saturdays
Late at night but met some nice chilled cool.people..girl behind the bar was so friendly too.. Worth a visit