I had 10 cards sent out to psa by SMR collectibles. I got back (6) Psa 10 (2) psa 9 (2) psa 8 I have to say you can’t win them all I’m pleased with the results. The cards were shipped back to my residence. Before they were shipped back to me SMR reached out to me to confirm the address they had was correct. The cards were shipped with care and I was given the tracking number. I’m pleased to say I will be doing business with SMR again. Thank you SMR
I had an excellent experience working with Steve at SMR Collectibles! He helped me trade up from a Michael Jordan Rookie PSA 7 to a PSA 8, and I couldn't be happier with the transaction. His customer service is top-notch—Steve took the time to ensure I was comfortable and fully informed throughout the process. The trade was smooth, and I'm thrilled with the Jordan rookie PSA 8 he secured for me. If you're looking to buy, trade, or need expert advice, I highly recommend Steve. He’s trustworthy, knowledgeable, and truly goes the extra mile to make sure his customers are satisfied!
Travis ManBun Burg
-
June 20, 2025
I wish I could give Ten Stars! Great place great store great seller and buyer and really knowledgeable staff!
Les Knittel
-
April 20, 2022
OUTSTANDING SELLING EXPERIENCE
Let me start by saying as a collector, you want to do business with someone who is honest and fairly priced. And as a customer, you want an establishment whose employees are knowledgeable, trustworthy, and friendly. SMR Collectibles is that place. Steve was great to deal with.
I scheduled an appointment with Steve and his employees, as I was looking to sell most of my sportscard collection. The biggest apprehension I had was that I would sell my cards for
too low or get low-balled. That was NOT the case. Steve was very transparent about prices, condition, rarity and even enlightened me about why some of my cards are very popular right now. He showed me what websites he uses to price cards, and made a spreadsheet for my higher end cards.
WE HAVE A DEAL! -- We consulted on what we both thought was a fair price and I ended up selling my collection of raw and graded cards to them. I actually got slightly over the number I had in my head and did not leave SMR feeling as if I were mislead.
On top of that, I saw SMR Steve set up at a local card show and he gave me some great deals. Easy to deal with.
Definitely will do business again with SMR Collectibles!
Our Address
169a New Hwy, Amityville, NY 11701, USA
Claim Listing: SMR Collectibles | We Buy Sports Cards | We Buy Sports Memorabilia | We Sell Sports Cards
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I had 10 cards sent out to psa by SMR collectibles. I got back (6) Psa 10 (2) psa 9 (2) psa 8 I have to say you can’t win them all I’m pleased with the results. The cards were shipped back to my residence. Before they were shipped back to me SMR reached out to me to confirm the address they had was correct. The cards were shipped with care and I was given the tracking number. I’m pleased to say I will be doing business with SMR again. Thank you SMR
Found SMR from Google/Instagram to sell Pokémon cards. Had a great conversation with manager Sam and owner Steve, they made me feel comfortable and were very transparent with the entire process (being my first time selling). Couldn’t recommend them more!
I had an excellent experience working with Steve at SMR Collectibles! He helped me trade up from a Michael Jordan Rookie PSA 7 to a PSA 8, and I couldn't be happier with the transaction. His customer service is top-notch—Steve took the time to ensure I was comfortable and fully informed throughout the process. The trade was smooth, and I'm thrilled with the Jordan rookie PSA 8 he secured for me. If you're looking to buy, trade, or need expert advice, I highly recommend Steve. He’s trustworthy, knowledgeable, and truly goes the extra mile to make sure his customers are satisfied!
I wish I could give Ten Stars! Great place great store great seller and buyer and really knowledgeable staff!
OUTSTANDING SELLING EXPERIENCE Let me start by saying as a collector, you want to do business with someone who is honest and fairly priced. And as a customer, you want an establishment whose employees are knowledgeable, trustworthy, and friendly. SMR Collectibles is that place. Steve was great to deal with. I scheduled an appointment with Steve and his employees, as I was looking to sell most of my sportscard collection. The biggest apprehension I had was that I would sell my cards for too low or get low-balled. That was NOT the case. Steve was very transparent about prices, condition, rarity and even enlightened me about why some of my cards are very popular right now. He showed me what websites he uses to price cards, and made a spreadsheet for my higher end cards. WE HAVE A DEAL! -- We consulted on what we both thought was a fair price and I ended up selling my collection of raw and graded cards to them. I actually got slightly over the number I had in my head and did not leave SMR feeling as if I were mislead. On top of that, I saw SMR Steve set up at a local card show and he gave me some great deals. Easy to deal with. Definitely will do business again with SMR Collectibles!