⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5‑Star Review for Vittorio’s Restaurant in Amityville, NY
Please Note***
I did not get anything free to write this. I just wanted to share my honest thoughts and opinions.
Vittorio’s in **Amityville, New York** is hands down my **favorite Italian restaurant on Long Island** — my absolute go‑to spot for authentic, delicious Italian food. Every time I dine here, I’m reminded why this place stands out among all the **top Italian restaurants on Long Island**.
If you ever get the pleasure of visiting **Vittorio’s Restaurant & Wine Bar**, I highly recommend trying the **Chicken Scarpiello** — it’s perfectly cooked, full of flavor, and truly one of the best dishes you’ll find anywhere. And if you go on a Sunday, do yourself a favor and order the **Sunday Sauce Pasta** with all the meats. Wow! It’s the kind of meal that makes you feel like you’re sitting at an Italian family table in the heart of Italy.
The service here is just as exceptional as the food. Our **server and bartender, Theresa**, was absolutely wonderful. I work late most nights and rarely get the chance to go out for dinner, but thanks to Theresa, we didn’t end up at the diner again. We arrived a little after 8 PM on a Sunday, right as the restaurant was winding down, and she still welcomed us with a smile and seated us without hesitation. Even though the staff was preparing to close, she never rushed us — instead, she made us feel completely at home. Which is pretty unheard of in 2025. I cant tell you how appreciative we are. It’s truly the little things like this that people remember. Other restaurant’s should take note
We started with our favorite appetizer, the **fried calamari**, which was crispy, tender, and cooked to perfection. Then came our entrées — rich, flavorful, and beautifully plated. Every bite reminded me why **Vittorio’s Amityville** is truly one of the **best Italian dining experiences on Long Island**.
What makes this restaurant even more special is the value. For a **five‑star Italian restaurant**, the portions are generous — you’ll almost always go home with enough for the next day (and maybe even the day after). The food, service, and atmosphere are worth every penny.
Vittorio’s is cozy, clean, and welcoming — a true gem on **Broadway in Amityville, NY**. You can taste the passion and care in every dish, and the staff treats you like family. There aren’t many restaurants left that combine **outstanding customer service**, **authentic Italian cuisine**, and a **warm, inviting atmosphere** quite like this one.
If I could give them 10 stars, I absolutely would. Thank you, **Theresa and the entire Vittorio’s team**, for another unforgettable dining experience. You’ve earned a lifelong customer.
Geri Antonacci
-
November 03, 2025
I haven’t been to Vittorio’s in a few years just because it’s expensive but when I’ve gone, their food/dinner was always amazing. Me and my boyfriend went Sunday for their brunch and our anniversary. 20$ per person for bottomless drinks? Can’t beat that when one drink is almost 20$ lol plus the menu and food was amazing. Our waiter/service was on point too! We will definitely be returning!
Lenny Rossello
-
March 27, 2025
My first time there with my girlfriend for her birthday. We both are gluten free, I have celiac disease but read that they are very safe to eat at their restaurant.
There menu items is not marked gluten free but out server was very know about what and what not to order. We started off with fried calamari for an app. It was absolutely delicious and not chewy at all.
Main course my girlfriend got the Halibut and I got the NY strip steak cooked medium rare with garlic spinach and roasted potatoes in a truffle Parmesan cheese. Steak was cooked on point and it had to weight 3 lbs if not more. I was ate the whole steak but it definitely took some time. Everything was so so good. We were stuffed. Unfortunately we didn't have room for dessert.
Caitlin O'Shaughnessy
-
October 28, 2025
I’ve always heard great things about this place and it did not disappoint.
Food was incredible….the crab cocktail appetizer and marinated skirt steak were both sooooo delicious. Steak was cooked perfectly and portions on everything were generous. Cocktails were amazing as was the service from Theresa!
Lauren Ciambriello
-
June 02, 2024
We came here with 12 people and we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. The food was delicious and satisfying. The portions are huge! So bring your appetite. I believe our waiters name was Andrea, he was very nice and helpful to answer any questions we had. We will definitely be coming back.
Our Address
184 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701, USA
Claim Listing: Vittorio’s
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5‑Star Review for Vittorio’s Restaurant in Amityville, NY Please Note*** I did not get anything free to write this. I just wanted to share my honest thoughts and opinions. Vittorio’s in **Amityville, New York** is hands down my **favorite Italian restaurant on Long Island** — my absolute go‑to spot for authentic, delicious Italian food. Every time I dine here, I’m reminded why this place stands out among all the **top Italian restaurants on Long Island**. If you ever get the pleasure of visiting **Vittorio’s Restaurant & Wine Bar**, I highly recommend trying the **Chicken Scarpiello** — it’s perfectly cooked, full of flavor, and truly one of the best dishes you’ll find anywhere. And if you go on a Sunday, do yourself a favor and order the **Sunday Sauce Pasta** with all the meats. Wow! It’s the kind of meal that makes you feel like you’re sitting at an Italian family table in the heart of Italy. The service here is just as exceptional as the food. Our **server and bartender, Theresa**, was absolutely wonderful. I work late most nights and rarely get the chance to go out for dinner, but thanks to Theresa, we didn’t end up at the diner again. We arrived a little after 8 PM on a Sunday, right as the restaurant was winding down, and she still welcomed us with a smile and seated us without hesitation. Even though the staff was preparing to close, she never rushed us — instead, she made us feel completely at home. Which is pretty unheard of in 2025. I cant tell you how appreciative we are. It’s truly the little things like this that people remember. Other restaurant’s should take note We started with our favorite appetizer, the **fried calamari**, which was crispy, tender, and cooked to perfection. Then came our entrées — rich, flavorful, and beautifully plated. Every bite reminded me why **Vittorio’s Amityville** is truly one of the **best Italian dining experiences on Long Island**. What makes this restaurant even more special is the value. For a **five‑star Italian restaurant**, the portions are generous — you’ll almost always go home with enough for the next day (and maybe even the day after). The food, service, and atmosphere are worth every penny. Vittorio’s is cozy, clean, and welcoming — a true gem on **Broadway in Amityville, NY**. You can taste the passion and care in every dish, and the staff treats you like family. There aren’t many restaurants left that combine **outstanding customer service**, **authentic Italian cuisine**, and a **warm, inviting atmosphere** quite like this one. If I could give them 10 stars, I absolutely would. Thank you, **Theresa and the entire Vittorio’s team**, for another unforgettable dining experience. You’ve earned a lifelong customer.
I haven’t been to Vittorio’s in a few years just because it’s expensive but when I’ve gone, their food/dinner was always amazing. Me and my boyfriend went Sunday for their brunch and our anniversary. 20$ per person for bottomless drinks? Can’t beat that when one drink is almost 20$ lol plus the menu and food was amazing. Our waiter/service was on point too! We will definitely be returning!
My first time there with my girlfriend for her birthday. We both are gluten free, I have celiac disease but read that they are very safe to eat at their restaurant. There menu items is not marked gluten free but out server was very know about what and what not to order. We started off with fried calamari for an app. It was absolutely delicious and not chewy at all. Main course my girlfriend got the Halibut and I got the NY strip steak cooked medium rare with garlic spinach and roasted potatoes in a truffle Parmesan cheese. Steak was cooked on point and it had to weight 3 lbs if not more. I was ate the whole steak but it definitely took some time. Everything was so so good. We were stuffed. Unfortunately we didn't have room for dessert.
I’ve always heard great things about this place and it did not disappoint. Food was incredible….the crab cocktail appetizer and marinated skirt steak were both sooooo delicious. Steak was cooked perfectly and portions on everything were generous. Cocktails were amazing as was the service from Theresa!
We came here with 12 people and we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. The food was delicious and satisfying. The portions are huge! So bring your appetite. I believe our waiters name was Andrea, he was very nice and helpful to answer any questions we had. We will definitely be coming back.